FLK1, Session 2 · Product liability

SQE1 Tort question: Principles of the Consumer Protection Act 1987

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 4

Principles of the Consumer Protection Act 1987Easier

A homeowner bought a washing machine manufactured by an appliance company. Due to a manufacturing defect in the internal drum, the machine malfunctioned and destroyed itself. No other property was damaged, and nobody was injured. The homeowner seeks compensation under the Consumer Protection Act 1987 for the machine.

Can the homeowner recover the cost of replacing the washing machine under the Consumer Protection Act 1987?

Show the answer and explanation
E

Correct answer

No, because the Act does not cover loss of or damage to the defective product itself.

Under s.5(2) of the Consumer Protection Act 1987, damage to the defective product itself is not recoverable.

The Consumer Protection Act 1987 provides compensation for death, personal injury, and damage to other private property. Under s.5(2), liability under section 2 does not arise in respect of loss of or damage to the product itself. Therefore, the homeowner cannot recover the replacement cost of the washing machine under the Act.

Section 5(2) of the Consumer Protection Act 1987 explicitly provides that 'damage' does not include the loss of or damage to the product itself. Remedy for the defective product itself lies in contract (e.g. against the seller under the Consumer Rights Act 2015).

  • Consumer Protection Act 1987, s.5(2) — Damage under the Act excludes loss of or damage to the product itself.

Rule card

CPA 1987 s.5(2): Damage under the Act does NOT include loss of or damage to the defective product itself. Remedy for the item itself lies in contract against the seller.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Surface readingClosest alternative

    Yes, because the washing machine is private domestic property and its replacement cost exceeds the statutory minimum threshold of £275.

    Although the washing machine is domestic property and its value exceeds £275 (the threshold in s.5(4)), s.5(2) of the CPA 1987 expressly provides that a person shall not be liable under s.2 for loss of or damage to the product itself.

    Ruled out by: The statutory exclusion in s.5(2) of the Consumer Protection Act 1987, which overrides the general property threshold.

    • Consumer Protection Act 1987, s.5(2), s.5(4) — Damage under the Act excludes loss of or damage to the product itself, regardless of whether property exceeds £275.
  • B
    Adjacent rule

    Yes, because the Act imposes strict liability for loss of or damage to any property caused by a defect in a product.

    While s.5(1) defines damage as including loss of or damage to any property, this is expressly made subject to the subsequent provisions of s.5. Section 5(2) explicitly provides that there is no liability under s.2 for loss of or damage to the product itself.

    • Consumer Protection Act 1987, s.5(1)-(2) — The statutory definition of damage to property in s.5(1) is subject to the express exclusion of the product itself in s.5(2).
  • C
    Adjacent rule

    No, because statutory claims for defective goods must be brought against the immediate seller rather than the manufacturer.

    Under s.2(2) of the Consumer Protection Act 1987, strict liability is imposed directly on the producer (manufacturer) of the product without requiring privity of contract. The claim fails instead because s.5(2) excludes liability for loss of or damage to the product itself.

    • Consumer Protection Act 1987, s.2(2) — Liability under the Act is imposed directly on the producer of the defective product rather than exclusively on the immediate supplier.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    No, because the homeowner must prove that the appliance company was negligent in manufacturing the washing machine.

    Liability under s.2(1) of the Consumer Protection Act 1987 is strict and does not require proof that the manufacturer was negligent. The claim fails instead because s.5(2) excludes liability for loss of or damage to the product itself.

    • Consumer Protection Act 1987, s.2(1) — Liability under the Act is strict upon proof of a defect causing damage and does not require proof of negligence.

Read with this question