Question 5
The rule in Rylands v FletcherMediumA local authority owns a multi-storey block of residential flats. It maintains a large cold-water storage tank and piping system in the roof space to supply domestic drinking water to the residents. Without any negligence by the local authority, a supply pipe unexpectedly fractured. A torrent of water escaped, flooding the basement of an adjoining commercial shop. The shopkeeper brings an action under the rule in Rylands v Fletcher.
Which of the following statements best explains whether the local authority is liable under the rule in Rylands v Fletcher?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer B
Correct answer
Not liable because supplying domestic water to residential flats does not constitute a non-natural use of land.
The local authority is not liable under Rylands v Fletcher because maintaining a domestic water supply system is a normal and ordinary use of land, not a non-natural use.
Under Transco plc v Stockport MBC [2003] UKHL 66, the requirement of 'non-natural use' requires an extraordinary and unusual use of land creating an exceptionally high risk. Piping water for ordinary domestic consumption to a block of flats is a completely ordinary and standard use of land. Because the use is natural/ordinary, the rule in Rylands v Fletcher cannot apply.
In Transco plc v Stockport MBC [2003] UKHL 66, the House of Lords held that the rule in Rylands v Fletcher requires an extraordinary and unusual use of land that poses an exceptionally high risk of danger. The provision of a piped water supply for normal domestic use to a block of flats is an entirely ordinary, routine, and natural use of land.
- Transco plc v Stockport MBC [2003] UKHL 66 — Domestic water piping to residential flats is an ordinary use of land, not a non-natural use under Rylands v Fletcher.
Rule card
For Rylands v Fletcher, the use of land must be non-natural (extraordinary and unusual). Supplying piped domestic water to domestic flats is an ordinary use (Transco v Stockport MBC).
Why the other options fail
- ASurface reading
Liable because the rule in Rylands v Fletcher imposes strict liability whenever an escape of water collected on land causes foreseeable damage.
The rule in Rylands v Fletcher requires a 'non-natural use' of land; collecting water for ordinary domestic supply is a natural and ordinary use.
- Transco plc v Stockport MBC [2003] UKHL 66 — Supplying water for ordinary domestic purposes through a piping system does not constitute a non-natural use of land.
- CSurface reading
Liable because storing a substantial volume of water in a roof space is an inherently dangerous non-natural activity.
Piping and tanks used to service domestic water needs in residential buildings are an ordinary and conventional feature of modern living, not a non-natural use.
- Transco plc v Stockport MBC [2003] UKHL 66 — Standard water tanks and pipes for domestic residential supply are not non-natural uses of land.
- DRight outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative
Not liable because the local authority took all reasonable care and was not negligent.
Rylands v Fletcher is a strict liability tort. If the elements were met, absence of negligence would not be a defence; liability fails instead on the non-natural use element.
Ruled out by: The fact that Rylands v Fletcher is a strict liability tort where lack of negligence is not a valid defence.
- Rylands v Fletcher (1868) LR 3 HL 330 — Liability under the rule is strict once the elements of non-natural use and dangerous escape are satisfied.
- EOutdated law
Not liable because pure water is incapable of being a dangerous thing.
Water can be a dangerous thing if accumulated in bulk under extraordinary conditions (as in Rylands v Fletcher itself); the issue here is non-natural use.
- Rylands v Fletcher (1868) LR 3 HL 330 — Water accumulated in an artificial reservoir can satisfy the dangerous thing element.