Question 3
DefencesMediumA customer visits an indoor shopping centre during normal trading hours to make a purchase. A maintenance cleaner mopping a polished tiled walkway near the food court leaves a large pool of soapy water across the thoroughfare without cordoning off the area. The cleaner places a single small warning cone behind a structural pillar several metres away, where it is obscured from the view of customers approaching along the main aisle. The customer walks briskly into the area while looking down at a mobile phone screen to read an urgent email, paying no attention to the path ahead. The customer steps directly onto the soapy surface, slips, and falls heavily to the ground, sustaining a fractured elbow and torn ligaments. The customer brings a claim for damages under the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957. The shopping centre asserts that the warning cone absolves it from all liability.
Which of the following best explains the shopping centre's liability under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer A
Correct answer
The centre is liable for breach of duty, but damages will be reduced for contributory negligence.
The shopping centre breached its duty of care because the obscured warning was inadequate to make the customer reasonably safe, but the customer's damages will be reduced for contributory negligence.
Under s.2(4)(a) of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, a warning does not absolve the occupier unless in all the circumstances it was enough to enable the visitor to be reasonably safe. An obscured cone behind a pillar where visitors cannot see it is inadequate, so the centre breached its common duty of care. However, the customer was walking briskly whilst reading a phone and not looking at the walkway. This constitutes a failure to take reasonable care for their own safety, entitling the centre to a reduction of damages for contributory negligence under s.1(1) of the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945.
Under s.2(4)(a) of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, a warning does not absolve the occupier unless it was enough to enable the visitor to be reasonably safe; an obscured cone behind a pillar is inadequate. However, the customer failed to take reasonable care for their own safety by walking briskly while looking only at a phone, so damages are reduced for contributory negligence under s.1(1) of the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945.
- Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, s.2(4)(a) — A warning is not to be treated without more as absolving the occupier from liability, unless in all the circumstances it was enough to enable the visitor to be reasonably safe.
- Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945, s.1(1) — Where any person suffers damage as the result partly of his own fault and partly of the fault of any other person, damages recoverable shall be reduced.
Rule card
OLA 1957 s.2(4)(a): A warning only absolves an occupier if it enables the visitor to be reasonably safe. Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945: Visitor's carelessness reduces damages.
Why the other options fail
- BSurface reading
The centre is not liable, because placing a recognized warning cone on the premises discharges the common duty of care to visitors regardless of its location.
Section 2(4)(a) of the 1957 Act expressly states that a warning is not to be treated without more as absolving the occupier unless in all the circumstances it was enough to enable the visitor to be reasonably safe. A hidden cone is ineffective.
- Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, s.2(4)(a) — A warning is not without more to be treated as absolving the occupier unless in all the circumstances it was enough to enable the visitor to be reasonably safe.
- CSurface reading
The centre is fully liable without any reduction, because visitors are not required to guard against liquid spillages inside commercial shopping centres.
Visitors are required to take reasonable care for their own safety. Walking while looking down at a phone screen constitutes contributory negligence, reducing damages.
- Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945, s.1(1) — Where a claimant's own fault contributed to their injury, their damages must be reduced.
- DAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
The centre is not liable, because the customer voluntarily assumed the risk of falling by walking whilst distracted.
Volenti non fit injuria (s.2(5) OLA 1957) requires full knowledge of the nature and extent of the risk and a free agreement to run it. The distracted customer was unaware of the puddle and did not consent to the risk of falling.
Ruled out by: Eliminated because volenti non fit injuria (s.2(5)) requires full knowledge and voluntary agreement to incur the legal risk; careless distraction constitutes contributory negligence, not consent.
- Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, s.2(5) — The common duty of care does not impose an obligation in respect of risks willingly accepted by the visitor.
- EAdjacent rule
The centre is not liable, because the customer's failure to look where they were walking broke the chain of causation.
A claimant's own negligence does not break the chain of causation unless it is so unreasonable and unforeseeable as to eclipse the defendant's breach entirely. Walking while distracted is a foreseeable form of carelessness that reduces damages under contributory negligence rather than breaking causation.
- Spencer v Wincanton Holdings Ltd [2009] EWCA Civ 1404 — A claimant's own careless conduct will not break the chain of causation unless it is so unreasonable as to eclipse the defendant's wrongdoing, and is otherwise addressed by contributory negligence.