Question 2
Employers’ primary liability (operation and effect of the common law principles)MediumA labourer at a scrap yard, who had sight in one eye only, was set to chip rust from steel beams. The yard, which carried compulsory employers' liability insurance, issued no goggles for chipping work, as no yard in the trade did; the chance of a fragment entering an eye during chipping was small. The labourer had never asked for goggles. A fragment struck his good eye and he is now blind.
Is the scrap yard in breach of the duty of care it owed the labourer?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer D
Correct answer
Yes, because the gravity of injury to a one-eyed employee made goggles a necessary precaution.
The employer's duty is tailored to the individual employee; a known disability raises the precautions reasonable care demands.
The yard knew the labourer had one good eye, so the gravity of an eye injury to him was blindness. That gravity outweighed the low probability of a fragment striking and the absence of any trade practice of issuing goggles.
The standard of care is owed to this employee. Knowing he had one good eye, the consequence of an eye injury was total blindness, so reasonable care required goggles even though the risk was low and the trade did not supply them.
- Paris v Stepney Borough Council — A known disability increasing the gravity of possible injury requires greater precautions.
Rule card
Employer's primary liability: reasonable care for the safety of each employee, judged on the likelihood of injury, the seriousness of the harm risked to that employee, and the cost and practicability of precautions. Trade practice is evidence only.
Why the other options fail
- ARight outcome, wrong reason
Yes, because an employer's duty to provide a safe workplace is strict.
The common law duty is to take reasonable care in the circumstances, not to guarantee safety.
- Wilsons & Clyde Coal Co Ltd v English — The employer's personal duty is to take reasonable care to provide competent staff, adequate plant, a safe place of work and a safe system.
- BRight outcome, wrong reason
No, because the employee never asked for goggles and the employer could rely on his silence.
The duty to take reasonable care for the employee's safety is the employer's own and is not suspended because the employee says nothing.
- General Cleaning Contractors Ltd v Christmas — The employer must consider and provide a safe system; it cannot leave safety to the initiative of the workman.
- CSurface readingClosest alternative
No, because the risk of a fragment entering an eye was too small to require any precaution.
Breach is judged on magnitude of risk and gravity of the potential harm together; a small risk of total blindness justified precautions.
Ruled out by: The labourer had sight in one eye only, so the potential injury was total blindness, which outweighs the small chance of a fragment striking.
- Paris v Stepney Borough Council — The seriousness of the potential injury to the individual employee is weighed with the likelihood of it occurring.
- EAdjacent rule
No, because the accepted practice in that industry was not to supply goggles for such work.
General practice is evidence of reasonable care but is not conclusive; a practice which overlooks a known special risk is no defence.
- Paris v Stepney Borough Council — Common practice does not determine what reasonable care requires for an employee with a known disability.