FLK1, Session 2 · Negligence

SQE1 Tort question: Claims for pure economic loss arising from either a negligent act or misstatement

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 1

Claims for pure economic loss arising from either a negligent act or misstatementMedium

A manufacturing company was operating an electric furnace to melt metal alloys. A construction contractor negligently severed the municipal power cable supplying electricity to the company's factory. The shut-down damaged the alloy batch currently in the furnace. The factory was also unable to process four further planned batches during the twelve-hour power outage.

Which of the following best describes the losses for which the company can recover damages in negligence from the contractor?

Show the answer and explanation
A

Correct answer

The damaged alloy and the loss of profit on that batch only, because profit lost on the uncommenced batches is irrecoverable pure economic loss.

The company can recover for the physical damage to the alloy in the furnace and the loss of profit on that batch, but cannot recover the lost profits on the four uncommenced batches.

Under the leading authority Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd [1973] QB 27, when a negligent act cuts off power, the claimant can recover for physical damage to their own property (the alloy in the furnace) and the consequential economic loss directly flowing from that physical damage (the lost profit on that batch). However, the loss of profit from the four batches that had not yet been put into the furnace is pure economic loss resulting from an interruption of power (damage to third-party property), which is irrecoverable in tort.

Under Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co, the claimant can recover for the physical damage to its property (the alloy in the furnace) and the consequential economic loss immediately flowing from that physical damage (lost profit on that melt). However, profits on subsequent batches that were never melted are pure economic loss unconnected to damage to the claimant's property and cannot be recovered.

  • Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd [1973] QB 27 — Physical damage to goods and consequential lost profits are recoverable, but pure economic loss from lost future production batches is not.

Rule card

In negligent act claims, pure economic loss is irrecoverable. Claimants can recover for physical damage to their own property and consequential economic loss (profits directly lost from the damaged property), but not for lost profits on prospective operations prevented by the outage (Spartan Steel).

Why the other options fail

  • B
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    All losses including the damaged alloy and all lost profits, because the loss of profits on the four uncommenced batches was directly caused by the physical damage to the municipal power cable.

    Damage to property belonging to a third party (the power cable owned by the electricity board) does not allow the claimant to recover financial losses that do not stem from damage to its own property.

    Ruled out by: The uncommenced four batches were never placed in the furnace and suffered no physical damage; their lost profits constitute pure economic loss, which Spartan Steel explicitly excludes.

    • Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd [1973] QB 27 — Financial loss resulting from damage to third-party property is pure economic loss and irrecoverable in negligence.
  • C
    Surface reading

    The damaged alloy batch only, because profits of any kind are classified as pure economic loss and are never recoverable in negligence.

    Loss of profit is recoverable where it is consequential economic loss directly stemming from physical damage to the claimant's own property.

    • Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd [1973] QB 27 — Loss of profit directly consequent upon physical damage to the claimant's property is recoverable.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    None of the losses, because the factory did not own the severed power cable and therefore suffered no actionable primary damage.

    Although the claimant did not own the cable, the claimant did own the molten alloy which suffered physical damage as a direct result of the contractor's negligent act, providing an actionable foundation in negligence.

    • Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd [1973] QB 27 — A claimant who suffers physical damage to their own goods due to a severed cable can recover for that damage and its direct consequential losses.
  • E
    Surface reading

    All losses, because the interruption to production was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of severing the electricity supply line.

    In claims for pure economic loss resulting from a negligent act, reasonable foreseeability alone does not establish a duty of care.

    • Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd [1973] QB 27 — Pure economic loss caused by a negligent act is not recoverable merely because it was a foreseeable result of the tort.

Read with this question