FLK1, Session 2 · Powers and procedures for the enactment, implementation and repeal of primary and secondary legislation by Westminster and by Senedd Cymru and Welsh Ministers Public Order Law

SQE1 Legal System question: Remedies

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 4

RemediesMedium

A market trader applied to a local authority for a street trading licence. The committee refused the application without considering his previous trading record, as the authority's own published policy required. The trader lost £12,000 of expected profits over the following season. The authority now accepts that its committee failed to follow that policy. The trader issues judicial review proceedings promptly, wanting to trade again this year. The licensing decision remains one for the authority's committee under the governing legislation.

Which of the following best describes the relief the court may grant?

Show the answer and explanation
A

Correct answer

A quashing order setting aside the refusal and remitting the application to the authority for lawful reconsideration.

The appropriate relief is to quash the refusal and send the application back for lawful reconsideration.

The committee failed to apply its own policy, so the decision may be quashed; but the licensing discretion remains the committee's under the governing legislation, so the court remits rather than decides.

The supervisory jurisdiction allows the court to quash an unlawful decision and require the decision to be retaken lawfully by the body entrusted with it.

  • Chief Constable of the North Wales Police v Evans [1982] 1 WLR 1155 — Review concerns the legality and manner of decision-making, not the merits.
  • R v Aston University Senate, ex p Roffey [1969] 2 QB 538 — Remedies are discretionary.

Rule card

Judicial review remedies: quashing, prohibiting and mandatory orders, declarations and injunctions, all discretionary; the court supervises and remits, and damages require an independent private law cause of action.

Why the other options fail

  • B
    Right outcome, wrong reason

    The court must grant relief as of right, since the authority has conceded that its committee acted unlawfully.

    Remedies in judicial review are discretionary; the court may refuse or limit relief even where a ground is established.

    • R v Aston University Senate, ex p Roffey [1969] 2 QB 538 — Relief in the supervisory jurisdiction is discretionary and may be refused notwithstanding established unlawfulness.
  • C
    Civil-law intuition

    Damages for the £12,000 lost profits, because the decision is admitted to be unlawful.

    There is no general right to damages for unlawful administrative action; a separate private law cause of action, such as misfeasance in public office, must be established.

    • Three Rivers District Council v Bank of England (No 3) [2003] 2 AC 1 — Compensation for unlawful public administration requires a recognised cause of action such as misfeasance in public office.
  • D
    Surface readingClosest alternative

    The court may substitute its own decision and grant the licence, the unlawfulness being admitted.

    The court's jurisdiction is supervisory; it does not exercise the licensing discretion conferred on the committee.

    Ruled out by: The governing legislation leaves the licensing decision to the authority's committee, so the court cannot substitute its own decision.

    • Chief Constable of the North Wales Police v Evans [1982] 1 WLR 1155 — The supervisory jurisdiction does not permit the court to decide the matter afresh.
  • E
    Adjacent rule

    A mandatory order requiring the authority to issue the licence to the trader without further consideration.

    A mandatory order compels performance of a public duty; it cannot dictate how a genuine discretion is exercised.

    • Padfield v Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food [1968] AC 997 — The court may compel lawful consideration but not a particular exercise of discretion.

Read with this question