Question 3
Parliamentary privilegeMediumDuring a debate in the House of Commons a Member of Parliament states that a construction company won a public contract by bribing officials. The company denies this. The following day the Member issues a press release to national newspapers repeating the allegation word for word, and says publicly that she is willing to defend her allegation in court. The company's solicitor has written to the Speaker asking the House of Commons to permit a defamation claim. In the same week a different Member is charged with dishonestly claiming parliamentary expenses.
Which of the following statements about parliamentary privilege is correct on these facts?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer E
Correct answer
The words spoken in the debate cannot be questioned in the claim, but the press release repeating them is actionable.
Privilege protects proceedings in Parliament, not the Member's extra-parliamentary repetition of the same words.
The debate is a proceeding in Parliament and cannot be questioned in litigation; the press release is a fresh publication outside Parliament and is actionable in the ordinary way.
Freedom of speech in Parliament prevents the court examining what was said in debate; the separate publication to newspapers is outside proceedings and may be sued upon.
- Church of Scientology of California v Johnson-Smith [1972] 1 QB 522 — Privilege covers words spoken in debate but not their repetition outside Parliament.
- R v Chaytor [2010] UKSC 52 — Privilege is confined to proceedings in Parliament.
Rule card
Freedom of speech in Parliament bars the courts from questioning proceedings in Parliament. It belongs to the House, cannot be waived by a member, and does not cover repetition outside the House or expenses claims.
Why the other options fail
- ARight outcome, wrong reason
The Member may waive privilege, so the claim can be brought on the words spoken in the debate.
The privilege of freedom of speech belongs to the House, not to the individual Member, and cannot be waived by her willingness to litigate.
- Prebble v Television New Zealand Ltd [1995] 1 AC 321 — The privilege protecting parliamentary proceedings is that of the House and is not at the disposal of an individual member.
- BAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
Privilege covers both the debate and the press release, because both concern the Member's parliamentary work.
Privilege attaches to proceedings in Parliament, not to the Member wherever she speaks; a press release to newspapers is not a proceeding, and repetition outside the House is actionable.
Ruled out by: The allegation was repeated in a press release issued to national newspapers, which is not a proceeding in Parliament however closely it tracks the debate.
- Church of Scientology of California v Johnson-Smith [1972] 1 QB 522 — Freedom of speech in Parliament protects proceedings in Parliament; statements repeated outside Parliament are not protected.
- CAdjacent rule
The claim may proceed on the debate only if the House of Commons resolves to permit it.
The courts will not question proceedings in Parliament; no resolution of the House converts a debate into evidence founding a defamation claim.
- Prebble v Television New Zealand Ltd [1995] 1 AC 321 — Courts will not allow parliamentary statements to be questioned in litigation, irrespective of the parties' or the House's wishes.
- DSurface reading
Privilege would equally prevent the prosecution of the other Member for dishonest expenses claims.
Submitting expenses claims is not a proceeding in Parliament, so privilege does not bar criminal prosecution of the Member.
- R v Chaytor [2010] UKSC 52 — Claims for parliamentary expenses are not proceedings in Parliament and are not protected by privilege.