Question 5
Schedule 1 HRA 1998 the "Convention Rights"MediumA woman brings proceedings in the High Court against a local authority. She complains that its conduct towards her showed discrimination on grounds of her religion, that it interfered with respect for her family life, and that it interfered with the peaceful enjoyment of her land. She also contends that the authority denied her any effective remedy, relying on Article 13 of the Convention. She seeks damages for the infringement. Her statement of case asserts that the Convention in its entirety forms part of the law of England and Wales. The authority's letter in reply refers to a designated reservation and denies that she has any enforceable rights.
Which of the following best describes whether the Articles on which the woman relies are "Convention rights" for the purposes of the Human Rights Act 1998?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer A
Correct answer
Article 13 is not one of the Convention rights, but Article 14 and Article 1 of the First Protocol are.
The Act incorporates a defined list of Articles; Article 13 is not on it, while Article 14 and the First Protocol rights are.
Section 1(1) defines the Convention rights as Articles 2 to 12 and 14 of the Convention, Articles 1 to 3 of the First Protocol and Article 1 of the Thirteenth Protocol, as read with Articles 16 to 18, and those Articles are set out in Schedule 1. The claim based on Article 13 therefore cannot be advanced as a Convention right.
The Act defines the Convention rights as Articles 2 to 12 and 14, Articles 1 to 3 of the First Protocol and Article 1 of the Thirteenth Protocol; Article 13 is omitted.
- Human Rights Act 1998, s.1(1) — Definition of "the Convention rights" by reference to specified Articles and Protocols.
- Human Rights Act 1998, s.1(3) — Those Articles are set out in Schedule 1.
Rule card
Convention rights under the Act: Convention Articles 2–12 and 14; First Protocol Articles 1–3; Thirteenth Protocol Article 1 — subject to any designated derogation or reservation.
Why the other options fail
- BSurface reading
All the Articles of the Convention and of every Protocol ratified by the United Kingdom are Convention rights, because Schedule 1 sets out the Convention in full.
The Act incorporates only the listed Articles; the definition is selective, and Article 13 in particular is not included.
- Human Rights Act 1998, s.1(1) — The Convention rights are confined to the Articles specifically listed in section 1(1).
- CAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
Article 13, the right to an effective remedy, is a Convention right, since the Act empowers courts to award damages for infringement.
The availability of remedies under the Act does not incorporate Article 13, which is deliberately absent from the definition of the Convention rights.
Ruled out by: Article 13 is outside the list in section 1(1); the fact that she seeks damages under the Act does not bring the effective remedy Article into domestic law.
- Human Rights Act 1998, s.1(1)(a) — The Convention Articles incorporated are Articles 2 to 12 and 14, so Article 13 is not a Convention right.
- DRight outcome, wrong reason
None of the rights relied on has effect, because of the designated reservation.
The Articles have effect subject to any designated derogation or reservation, but a reservation limits only the Article to which it relates; it does not remove the Convention rights generally.
- Human Rights Act 1998, s.1(2) — The Articles have effect for the purposes of the Act subject to any designated derogation or reservation.
- EAdjacent rule
Only Articles 2 to 12 and 14 of the Convention are Convention rights; the rights in the First Protocol are not incorporated by the Act.
Articles 1 to 3 of the First Protocol are expressly included in the definition of the Convention rights.
- Human Rights Act 1998, s.1(1)(b) — Articles 1 to 3 of the First Protocol are Convention rights for the purposes of the Act.