FLK1, Session 2 · The courts

SQE1 Legal System question: Court hierarchy, the appeal systemand jurisdiction

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 2

Court hierarchy, the appeal systemand jurisdictionMedium

A company lost a claim tried in the Chancery Division of the High Court. The judge's decision turned entirely on the construction of a section of a recent taxation statute, an issue on which businesses across the country urgently need a ruling. The company's solicitor wants the matter resolved by the Supreme Court as quickly as possible.

Which of the following best describes the availability of an appeal direct from the High Court to the Supreme Court?

Show the answer and explanation
A

Correct answer

Such an appeal is possible only where the trial judge grants a certificate on a point of law of general public importance and the Supreme Court grants permission to appeal.

A leapfrog appeal from the High Court to the Supreme Court requires both a certificate from the trial judge and permission from the Supreme Court.

Under sections 12 and 13 of the Administration of Justice Act 1969 (as amended), an appeal may bypass the Court of Appeal and proceed direct from the High Court to the Supreme Court ('leapfrog') only if two statutory requirements are met. First, the trial judge must grant a certificate indicating that the decision involves a point of law of general public importance (here relating wholly or mainly to the construction of an enactment). Second, following the grant of the certificate, the Supreme Court must grant permission to appeal.

A leapfrog appeal from the High Court to the Supreme Court under the Administration of Justice Act 1969 requires two cumulative steps: the trial judge must grant a certificate confirming that the statutory conditions are satisfied (here, a point of law of general public importance relating to statutory construction), and the Supreme Court must subsequently grant permission to appeal.

  • Administration of Justice Act 1969, s. 12 — The trial judge may grant a certificate where a point of law of general public importance relates wholly or mainly to the construction of an enactment.
  • Administration of Justice Act 1969, s. 13 — Where a certificate is granted under section 12, an appeal lies to the Supreme Court only if the Supreme Court grants permission to appeal.

Rule card

Leapfrog appeals (High Court to Supreme Court): requires (1) a certificate from the trial judge on a point of law of general public importance (relating to statutory construction or binding appellate precedent) and (2) permission to appeal granted by the Supreme Court (Administration of Justice Act 1969, ss. 12–13).

Why the other options fail

  • B
    Adjacent rule

    Such an appeal is possible only if the Court of Appeal first grants permission to appeal to the Supreme Court.

    The Court of Appeal does not grant permission for a leapfrog appeal; the procedure bypasses the Court of Appeal entirely, and an application for permission must be made directly to the Supreme Court.

    • Administration of Justice Act 1969, s. 13(1) — An application for permission to appeal direct to the Supreme Court is determined by the Supreme Court, not the Court of Appeal.
  • C
    Adjacent rule

    Such an appeal is not available because leapfrog appeals are restricted to cases where the judge was bound by a precedent of the Court of Appeal or Supreme Court.

    Under section 12(3) of the Administration of Justice Act 1969, leapfrog appeals are not restricted to cases involving binding precedent; a point of law of general public importance relating wholly or mainly to statutory construction provides an independent alternative ground.

    • Administration of Justice Act 1969, s. 12(3) — A certificate may be granted if the point of law of general public importance relates wholly or mainly to the construction of an enactment, as an alternative to involving a binding appellate precedent.
  • D
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    The trial judge may certify the appeal to the Supreme Court, and no further permission is then needed.

    The trial judge's certificate does not dispense with the requirement to obtain permission to appeal; under section 13 of the Administration of Justice Act 1969, permission must still be sought from and granted by the Supreme Court.

    Ruled out by: The trial judge's certificate is a necessary gateway, but it does not dispense with the requirement to obtain permission to appeal from the Supreme Court.

    • Administration of Justice Act 1969, s. 13(1) — A certificate granted by the trial judge does not dispense with the requirement to apply for and obtain permission to appeal from the Supreme Court.
  • E
    Outdated law

    Such an appeal is possible only if all parties to the claim consent to the application to bypass the Court of Appeal.

    Under section 12(1) of the Administration of Justice Act 1969 (as amended by the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015), an application for a certificate may be made by any party to the proceedings; the consent of all parties is no longer mandatory.

    • Administration of Justice Act 1969, s. 12(1) — An application for a leapfrog certificate may be made by any of the parties to the proceedings.

Read with this question