Question 1
Thejudicial functionjudiciaryHarderThe head of the judiciary of England and Wales is considering three proposals. The first is a new programme of specialist training for judges hearing complex fraud trials; the programme would require substantial additional expenditure, and the Ministry of Justice has indicated that the budget allocated to judicial training cannot be increased this year. The second is the transfer of two circuit judges from one court centre to another to reduce a backlog of cases. The third is that he should himself sit for a week in the county court to hear a substantial contract claim. A solicitor is asked to advise.
Which of the following statements best describes the position?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer C
Correct answer
The Lord Chief Justice is responsible for judicial training arrangements, but only within the resources made available by the Lord Chancellor.
Responsibility for judicial training rests with the Lord Chief Justice, but it is a resource-limited responsibility.
Under the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 the Lord Chief Justice, as President of the Courts of England and Wales and Head of the Judiciary, is responsible for maintaining appropriate arrangements for the welfare, training and guidance of the judiciary — expressly within the resources made available by the Lord Chancellor. He is also responsible for deployment and allocation of work, and is entitled to sit in the county court.
This states both limbs of the statutory responsibility: the head of the judiciary maintains the arrangements, but only to the extent of the resources the Lord Chancellor provides.
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s.7(2)(b) — The Lord Chief Justice is responsible for maintaining appropriate arrangements for the welfare, training and guidance of the judiciary within the resources made available by the Lord Chancellor.
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s.7(4) — The courts of which the Lord Chief Justice is president include the county court.
Rule card
CRA 2005 s.7: LCJ is Head of the Judiciary and President of the Courts of England and Wales; responsible for (a) representing judicial views to Parliament and Ministers, (b) welfare, training and guidance arrangements within the Lord Chancellor's resources, (c) deployment and allocation of work; entitled to sit in the listed courts.
Why the other options fail
- ARight outcome, wrong reason
The Lord Chancellor, and not the Lord Chief Justice, is responsible for the training of the judiciary, because he makes the resources available.
Providing the resources is not the same as holding the responsibility: the statute places responsibility for maintaining training arrangements on the Lord Chief Justice, while the Lord Chancellor makes resources available.
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s.7(2)(b) — The Lord Chief Justice is responsible for the maintenance of appropriate arrangements for the welfare, training and guidance of the judiciary within the resources made available by the Lord Chancellor.
- BAdjacent rule
Transferring judges between court centres is a matter for the Lord Chancellor alone.
Deployment of the judiciary and the allocation of work within courts are the responsibility of the Lord Chief Justice, not the Lord Chancellor.
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s.7(2)(c) — The Lord Chief Justice is responsible for the maintenance of appropriate arrangements for the deployment of the judiciary and the allocation of work within courts.
- DSurface readingClosest alternative
The Lord Chief Justice is responsible for the training of the judiciary, and that responsibility is unaffected by any limit placed on the available budget.
The first half is right, but the duty is expressly limited to the resources made available by the Lord Chancellor, so a budget limit does bear on what arrangements can be maintained.
Ruled out by: The scenario states that the programme needs substantial additional expenditure and that the allocated training budget cannot be increased; the statutory responsibility is exercisable only within the resources made available by the Lord Chancellor, so the budget limit is not irrelevant.
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s.7(2)(b) — The responsibility for training arrangements is expressed to be within the resources made available by the Lord Chancellor.
- EAdjacent rule
The Lord Chief Justice may not sit in the county court, because the county court is not one of the Senior Courts.
It is true that the county court is not a Senior Court, but the Lord Chief Justice is president of the county court and is entitled to sit in it.
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s.7(3)–(4) — The President of the Courts of England and Wales is president of the listed courts, which include the county court, and is entitled to sit in any of them.
- Senior Courts Act 1981, s.1 — The Senior Courts consist of the Court of Appeal, the High Court and the Crown Court.