FLK2, Session 1 · Grants of representation

SQE1 Wills and the Administration of Estates question: Personal representatives

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 4

Personal representativesHarder

A woman died in June last year. Eighteen months before her death she gave £300,000 in cash to her nephew, who has since emigrated and cannot be traced. No inheritance tax has been paid on that gift. Her will leaves her residuary estate, worth £400,000, to her sister. Her executors obtained probate four months after the death. Fourteen months have now passed since the end of the month in which she died, and nothing has been distributed from the residuary estate.

Which of the following best describes the position on liability for the inheritance tax attributable to the gift?

Show the answer and explanation
C

Correct answer

The nephew is primarily liable, but the executors became liable once the tax remained unpaid twelve months after the end of the month of death.

Tax on a failed potentially exempt transfer is primarily the donee's; the personal representatives become liable if it is still unpaid twelve months after the end of the month of death, and then only up to the value of the assets they have or could have received.

The gift eighteen months before death is a failed potentially exempt transfer. The nephew, as transferee, bears primary liability. Because the tax remains unpaid and more than twelve months have elapsed since the end of the month of death, the executors are now within the class of persons liable, subject to the statutory limit on their liability.

Primary liability falls on the donee; the personal representatives are the statutory backstop for unpaid tax on a lifetime transfer after twelve months, and their liability is capped by reference to the assets they have received or might have received.

  • Inheritance Tax Act 1984, s.199 — Identifies the persons liable for tax on a chargeable lifetime transfer, including the transferee and the transferor's personal representatives.
  • Inheritance Tax Act 1984, s.204 — Limits personal representatives' liability for inheritance tax by reference to the assets received or which they might have received.
  • Inheritance Tax Act 1984, s.211 — Tax on property vesting in the personal representatives is borne as a general testamentary expense.

Rule card

Lifetime transfer becoming chargeable on death: donee primarily liable; personal representatives liable for unpaid tax after twelve months from the end of the month of death, limited to the assets received or which might have been received. Tax on the free estate, by contrast, is borne as a general testamentary expense.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Adjacent rule

    The executors must pay the tax out of the residuary estate as a general testamentary expense.

    The general testamentary expense rule applies to tax on property in the United Kingdom which vests in the personal representatives; the cash given away eighteen months before death never vested in them.

    • Inheritance Tax Act 1984, s.211 — Tax on property in the United Kingdom which vests in the personal representatives and was not comprised in a settlement immediately before the death is borne as part of the general testamentary expenses.
  • B
    Surface readingClosest alternative

    The executors have no liability for the tax on the gift; liability rests solely on the nephew.

    The transferee is primarily liable, but that liability is not exclusive: the personal representatives may be pursued once the tax has remained unpaid for twelve months from the end of the month of death.

    Ruled out by: Fourteen months have passed since the end of the month in which she died and the tax is still unpaid, which is exactly what brings the executors within the class of persons liable.

    • Inheritance Tax Act 1984, s.199 — The transferee of a chargeable lifetime transfer is among the persons liable for the tax on the value transferred.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    The executors are jointly liable with the nephew for the whole of the tax from the date of death, without any limit on the amount recoverable from them.

    Personal representatives are not liable from the death for tax on a lifetime transfer, and in any event their liability is limited by reference to the assets they received or might have received.

    • Inheritance Tax Act 1984, s.204 — Caps the liability of personal representatives for inheritance tax by reference to the assets received or which they might have received.
  • E
    Right outcome, wrong reason

    The tax must be paid out of the £400,000 residuary estate as a testamentary expense, and the executors may afterwards recover the amount from the nephew.

    The burden does fall ultimately on the donee, but the residue is not the source of payment: the testamentary expense rule is confined to property vesting in the personal representatives.

    • Inheritance Tax Act 1984, s.211 — Tax on property vesting in the personal representatives is borne as a general testamentary expense, subject to any contrary direction in the will.

Read with this question