Question 5
Preserve the value of the estateMediumA man died three weeks ago. His will leaves his entire estate to his two adult children and appoints a family friend as sole executor. The estate includes an unoccupied house, whose contents include two valuable paintings, and a portfolio of quoted shares which has fallen by 15% since the date of death. The executor has instructed solicitors, but the inheritance tax account has not yet been submitted and neither has the application for the grant of probate. The buildings and contents insurance on the house expired last week.
What should the executor do next?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer B
Correct answer
Insure the house and its contents against loss or damage without delay.
The executor's immediate duty is to secure and preserve the estate's assets, which here means reinstating insurance on the empty house and its contents.
The house is unoccupied, contains valuable paintings and is uninsured. An executor's authority runs from death, so the cover should be put in place at once rather than after the grant or after the tax account is filed.
The duty to collect in and preserve the estate requires the executor to secure vulnerable assets. An unoccupied house containing valuable paintings with lapsed cover is the obvious immediate risk.
- Administration of Estates Act 1925, s.25(a) — Duty to collect and get in the real and personal estate of the deceased and administer it according to law.
Rule card
Preserve the estate: secure and insure vulnerable assets immediately; an executor may act from the date of death.
Why the other options fail
- ASurface reading
Sell the portfolio of quoted shares immediately to prevent any further fall in their value.
There is no duty to liquidate a fallen portfolio at once; the executor must act prudently, and a forced sale three weeks after death is not the pressing step where insurance has lapsed.
- Administration of Estates Act 1925, s.25(a) — The duty is to administer the estate according to law, which requires prudent management rather than immediate realisation of every asset.
- CAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
Wait until the grant of probate is issued before dealing with the house or its contents.
An executor's authority derives from the will and takes effect from death, so protective steps can and must be taken before the grant. Waiting would leave the house and paintings uninsured.
Ruled out by: The executor's title comes from the will, not the grant, so the fact that the probate application has not been submitted does not prevent protective action.
- Administration of Estates Act 1925, s.25(a) — The personal representative is under a duty to collect and get in the estate and administer it according to law.
- DCivil-law intuition
Ask the two adult children to arrange cover, because the estate passes to them at the date of death.
The assets vest in the executor for the purposes of administration, not in the beneficiaries; responsibility for protecting them is the executor's.
- Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996, s.18(2)(a) — In applying the Part to personal representatives, references to beneficiaries are replaced by references to persons interested in the due administration of the estate.
- EAdjacent rule
Take no step in relation to the house until the inheritance tax account has been submitted and any tax due has been paid.
The inheritance tax account and the grant application are separate from the executor's continuing duty to preserve the assets; protective steps come first.
- Administration of Estates Act 1925, s.25(a) — The duty to collect in and administer the estate applies from death and is not postponed until tax is accounted for.