Question 3
CodicilMediumA man made a valid will three years ago. He telephones his solicitor to say that he no longer wishes a legacy of £10,000 to a former colleague to take effect, but he wants all the other gifts to stand unchanged. The legacy appears on the second page alongside several other legacies that he wishes to preserve. He asks whether he could simply cross it out, or send his executors a signed letter.
How should the solicitor best proceed?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer C
Correct answer
Prepare a codicil for the client to execute with the same formalities as a will.
A single legacy can be revoked by a properly executed codicil, leaving the remainder of the will untouched.
Section 20 of the Wills Act 1837 permits revocation of a will 'or any part thereof' by a codicil executed in the manner required for a will. A codicil expressly revoking the £10,000 legacy achieves partial revocation while leaving the client's other gifts in force.
Under s.20 of the Wills Act 1837, a codicil executed in the manner required for a will may revoke part of an existing will. A codicil expressly revoking the single legacy leaves the remaining provisions intact, fulfilling the client's instructions.
- Wills Act 1837, s.20 — No will or codicil, or any part thereof, shall be revoked otherwise than by another will or codicil executed in manner herein-before required, or by some writing declaring an intention to revoke the same, and executed in the manner in which a will is herein-before required to be executed, or by the burning, tearing, or otherwise destroying the same with the intention of revoking the same.
Rule card
Revocation of part of a will: a codicil executed like a will can revoke a specific gift while leaving the remainder in force. Symbolic destruction and unexecuted writings do not revoke gifts unless words are rendered completely non-apparent.
Why the other options fail
- AAdjacent rule
Prepare a new will revoking all former wills, since a codicil cannot revoke only part of an existing will.
A codicil can revoke part of an existing will: s.20 of the Wills Act 1837 explicitly provides that a will 'or any part thereof' may be revoked by a later will or codicil, so making an entirely new will is unnecessary.
- Wills Act 1837, s.20 — A will or codicil 'or any part thereof' may be revoked by another will or codicil executed in the manner required.
- BSurface reading
Advise the client that his signed letter to the executors will revoke the legacy without witnesses.
Under s.20 of the Wills Act 1837, any writing declaring an intention to revoke must be executed in the manner in which a will is required to be executed; an unwitnessed letter does not satisfy these statutory formalities.
- Wills Act 1837, s.20 — Revocation may be by 'some writing declaring an intention to revoke the same, and executed in the manner in which a will is herein-before required to be executed'.
- DAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
Advise the client to tear off and destroy the second page containing the legacy.
Tearing off and destroying the second page would also destroy the other legacies on that page, directly contrary to the client's express instruction that all the other gifts must stand unchanged.
Ruled out by: The second page contains other gifts that the man wants to keep; tearing off and destroying that page would destroy those other gifts as well as the legacy, defeating his instructions.
- Wills Act 1837, s.20 — A will or codicil, or any part thereof, may be revoked by burning, tearing, or otherwise destroying the same with the intention of revoking it.
- ESurface reading
Advise the client that crossing out the legacy in his own hand and writing 'revoked' beside it will be effective.
Scoring through wording and writing 'revoked' is merely symbolic destruction rather than physical destruction under s.20 of the Wills Act 1837; unless the alteration is executed with the formalities required for a will, or the original words are completely obliterated so that they are no longer apparent, the original gift remains valid.
- Wills Act 1837, s.20 — A will or any part of it may be revoked by burning, tearing, or otherwise destroying it with the intention of revoking it; striking through words does not constitute destruction.
- Cheese v Lovejoy (1877) 2 PD 251 — Striking lines through parts of a will and writing words of revocation upon it constitutes symbolic destruction, which is insufficient to effect revocation under the statute.