FLK2, Session 1 · Validity of wills and codicils

SQE1 Wills and the Administration of Estates question: Formal requirements

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 2

Formal requirementsEasier

A solicitor posted a will to a client to sign at home. The residue is given to the client's daughter. The client signed in the presence of her neighbour and her daughter, both present together. The daughter signed in the client's presence, and the neighbour signed a few minutes later in the client's presence, after the daughter had gone outside. The client, who is in good health, has returned the will to the solicitor and asks whether anything more is needed.

What should the solicitor do next?

Show the answer and explanation
A

Correct answer

Arrange for the client to execute a fresh will in the office, witnessed by two people who are neither beneficiaries nor married to beneficiaries

The will was validly executed under s 9 Wills Act 1837, but because the daughter attested it, the gift of residue to her is void under s 15; a fresh will should be executed with independent witnesses.

The client signed in the presence of two witnesses present at the same time, and each witness signed in the client's presence, satisfying s 9 Wills Act 1837 (witnesses need not sign in each other's presence). However, under s 15 Wills Act 1837, a gift to an attesting witness is utterly null and void. Because the client is alive and has capacity, the proper course is to have a fresh will executed and attested by two independent witnesses who are neither beneficiaries nor spouses of beneficiaries.

The will was duly executed under s 9 Wills Act 1837, but the daughter's attestation makes the gift of residue to her utterly null and void under s 15. As the client is alive and in good health, the appropriate next step is to arrange for the execution of a fresh will with two independent witnesses.

  • Wills Act 1837, s 9 — No will is valid unless signed by the testator in the presence of two or more witnesses present at the same time, each of whom attests and signs or acknowledges in the presence of the testator (but not necessarily in the presence of any other witness).
  • Wills Act 1837, s 15 — A beneficial gift to an attesting witness or the spouse of an attesting witness is utterly null and void, while the will itself remains valid.

Rule card

Witnesses need not sign in each other's presence under s 9 Wills Act 1837. Attestation by a beneficiary does not invalidate the will, but renders that beneficiary's gift void under s 15. The defect is cured by executing a fresh will with independent witnesses.

Why the other options fail

  • B
    Surface reading

    Advise that the will is wholly invalid and the estate will pass on intestacy

    Attestation by a beneficiary does not invalidate the will itself. Under s 15 Wills Act 1837, only the beneficial gift to the attesting witness is null and void, and the witness remains competent to prove execution of the will.

    • Wills Act 1837, s 15 — A beneficial gift to an attesting witness is utterly null and void, but the attesting witness is admitted to prove execution and the will itself remains valid.
  • C
    Adjacent rule

    Advise that the will is invalid because the two witnesses did not sign in each other's presence, and arrange for the client alone to sign it again in front of the same witnesses

    Section 9(1)(d) Wills Act 1837 requires each witness to attest and sign (or acknowledge) in the presence of the testator, but expressly provides that they need not sign in the presence of any other witness. Furthermore, having the client re-sign before the same witnesses would not cure the forfeiture under s 15.

    • Wills Act 1837, s 9 — Each witness must attest and sign or acknowledge their signature in the presence of the testator, but not necessarily in the presence of any other witness.
  • D
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    Prepare a codicil confirming the will, to be executed by the client and attested by the same two witnesses

    Under the doctrine of republication, a codicil confirming a will can save a gift that was void under s 15 Wills Act 1837, but only if the codicil is attested by independent witnesses. If the daughter attests the codicil as well, the gift remains void under s 15.

    Ruled out by: Confirmation of a will by a codicil can save a gift previously void under s 15 Wills Act 1837, but only if the codicil is attested by independent witnesses; if the daughter attests the codicil as well, the gift remains void.

    • Wills Act 1837, s 15 — Any beneficial gift to an attesting witness or to the wife or husband of such person is utterly null and void.
  • E
    Surface reading

    Advise the client that the will is valid and that no further action is required

    Although the will satisfies the formal execution requirements of s 9 Wills Act 1837, the gift of residue to the daughter is void under s 15 because she attested the will. Advising that no further action is required would leave the client's primary testamentary wish defeated.

    • Wills Act 1837, s 15 — A beneficial gift to an attesting witness is utterly null and void.

Read with this question