Question 1
Wills and IntestacyHarderA man made a valid will in 2016. It appointed his wife sole executrix, gave a legacy of £10,000 to his sister and continued: 'I give the residue of my estate to my wife, but if my wife shall predecease me I give the residue to my brother.' The couple separated in 2018 and the final order dissolving the marriage was made in 2020. The man never made another will or codicil and did not remarry. He died last month, survived by his former wife, his brother, his sister and two adult children from an earlier relationship. The former wife received a lump sum on the divorce and has not remarried. The estate, after debts and inheritance tax, is worth £500,000.
Who is entitled to the residue of the man's estate?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer D
Correct answer
The brother, because the former wife is treated as having predeceased the man.
Dissolution does not revoke the will; the former wife is treated as having predeceased, so the express substitutional gift to the brother takes effect.
Under s.18A Wills Act 1837 property given to a former spouse passes as if she had died at the date of the final order. The residue clause provides expressly for the wife predeceasing, so the brother takes the £500,000 residue.
Section 18A treats the former wife as having died at the date of the final order, so the condition in the substitutional gift is satisfied and the brother takes the residue.
- Wills Act 1837, s.18A — Effect of dissolution of marriage on gifts to a former spouse.
- Administration of Estates Act 1925, s.46 — Intestacy applies only to property not disposed of by will.
Rule card
Divorce: will not revoked, but the former spouse is treated as having died at the date of dissolution. Look for an express substitutional gift before reaching for partial intestacy.
Why the other options fail
- ARight outcome, wrong reason
The former wife, because the dissolution of a marriage does not revoke a will or invalidate the gifts made in it.
The dissolution does not revoke the will, but a former spouse is treated as having died before the testator, so the gift to her cannot take effect.
- Wills Act 1837, s.18A — Where a marriage is dissolved or annulled, any property which the will gives to the former spouse passes as if the former spouse had died on the date of the dissolution or annulment.
- BAdjacent rule
The two adult children in equal shares, taking by substitution under section 33 of the Wills Act 1837 in place of the former wife.
Section 33 substitutes the issue of a child or remoter descendant of the testator who predeceases; the former wife is not the testator's issue and the children are not her issue.
- Wills Act 1837, s.33 — Where a gift is made to a child or remoter descendant of the testator who dies before the testator leaving issue, the gift takes effect as a gift to that issue.
- CAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
The two adult children in equal shares, because the gift of residue fails and the residue passes on partial intestacy.
The gift to the former wife does fail, but the will provides expressly for that event, so the residue is disposed of and no intestacy arises.
Ruled out by: The residue clause expressly provides 'but if my wife shall predecease me I give the residue to my brother', so the residue is disposed of and there is no intestacy.
- Administration of Estates Act 1925, s.46 — The intestacy rules apply only to property not effectively disposed of by the will.
- EAdjacent rule
The two adult children, the will having been revoked by the divorce.
Marriage revokes a will; dissolution of a marriage does not. The 2016 will remains valid apart from the gifts to the former wife.
- Wills Act 1837, s.18 — A will is revoked by the testator's marriage or formation of a civil partnership, subject to the exception for a will made in expectation of that marriage.
- Wills Act 1837, s.18A — Dissolution does not revoke the will; it causes property given to the former spouse to pass as if the former spouse had died at the date of dissolution.