Question 2
The rule in Saunders v VautierMediumTrustees hold a fund of £800,000 on trust to pay the income to a widower for life, and on his death to hold the capital for the settlor's nephew absolutely. The widower is 68 and the nephew is 40; both have capacity. Together they ask the trustees to wind the trust up now, with the widower taking 30% and the nephew 70%. The trustees think this unfair to the widower and suggest putting the matter before a judge.
Are the trustees bound to give effect to the beneficiaries' request?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer A
Correct answer
Yes, because between them the beneficiaries are absolutely entitled to the fund.
A life tenant and remainderman, both adult and of capacity, are between them absolutely entitled and may end the trust on terms of their own choosing.
Their two interests exhaust the beneficial ownership of the £800,000. Since both are in existence, ascertained, 18 or over, capable and in agreement, the trustees must comply, even with a split that differs from the deed.
The life tenant and the remainderman together exhaust the beneficial interest; both are adults with capacity and agree, so they may direct the trustees and choose the division.
- Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115 — Beneficiaries absolutely entitled between them control the destination of the trust property.
Rule card
Extended Saunders v Vautier: all beneficiaries, between them absolutely entitled, adult, capable and unanimous, can direct a transfer and rewrite the division.
Why the other options fail
- BRight outcome, wrong reason
No, because the trustees consider the split unfair to the life tenant and owe him a duty.
Fairness between beneficiaries is not for the trustees to police where the beneficiaries are absolutely entitled and unanimous; the property belongs to them.
- Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115 — Where beneficiaries absolutely entitled agree, the trustees must comply with their choice.
- CSurface reading
No, because the life tenant's interest is limited to income and gives him no say over the capital.
A life interest is a beneficial interest; combined with the remainder it exhausts the beneficial ownership, so the life tenant's agreement counts.
- Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115 — A life tenant and remainderman are between them absolutely entitled to the trust fund.
- DAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
No, because the proposed shares depart from the division of interests set out in the trust deed.
Beneficiaries who are between them absolutely entitled may agree any division they wish; the deed's terms do not constrain them.
Ruled out by: The 30/70 split departs from the deed, but the beneficiaries' collective absolute entitlement lets them override the settlor's terms.
- Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115 — Beneficiaries absolutely entitled between them may effectively override the terms of the original trust.
- EAdjacent rule
No, because the terms of a trust may only be departed from with the approval of the court.
No application is needed where all the beneficiaries are adults with capacity and are between them absolutely entitled; court approval is required where some beneficiary cannot consent.
- Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115 — Adult, capable beneficiaries absolutely entitled between them may end the trust without recourse to the court.