FLK2, Session 1 · Creation and requirements of express trusts

SQE1 Trusts Law question: Discretionary trusts

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 1

Discretionary trustsHarder

Five years ago a settlor executed a deed transferring £900,000 to three trustees, to be held for such of the settlor's children as the trustees should select, in such shares as they thought fit. The deed also empowers the trustees to add any future grandchild of the settlor to the class of beneficiaries. The settlor has three children, aged 24, 27 and 30, and the trustees have in practice distributed the trust income equally between the three children each year. Last month the trustees executed a deed of appointment appointing £50,000 of capital to the youngest child absolutely; the payment has not yet been made. That child now wishes to charge her interest under the trust to a lender.

Which of the following best describes the youngest child's interest in the trust fund?

Show the answer and explanation
D

Correct answer

She has a vested equitable interest in the £50,000 appointed to her, but no interest in the rest of the fund.

An object of a discretionary trust has no proprietary interest until the discretion is exercised; once it is, the appointed sum is hers in equity.

The trustees' deed of appointment gave the youngest child a vested equitable interest in £50,000, which she can charge. In respect of the remaining £850,000 she is still only an object, with a hope of benefit and a right to due consideration.

The deed of appointment exercised the discretion in her favour, so that sum is hers in equity and can be charged; as to the balance she remains a mere object with a hope of benefit.

  • Gartside v IRC [1968] AC 553 — An object of a discretionary trust has no interest in the fund unless and until the trustees exercise their discretion in their favour.
  • Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115 — Only ascertained beneficiaries of full capacity who are together absolutely entitled may collapse the trust.

Rule card

Discretionary trust object: spes plus right to be considered; exercise of the discretion converts that into a proprietary equitable interest in the appointed property.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Adjacent rule

    She has an equitable interest in one third of the fund, since the trustees have always distributed the income equally between the children.

    A past practice of equal distribution does not convert a discretionary trust into a fixed interest trust; the trustees remain free to select and to vary shares.

    • McPhail v Doulton [1971] AC 424 — Under a discretionary trust the objects' entitlement depends on the trustees' selection, not on fixed shares.
  • B
    Surface readingClosest alternative

    She has no equitable interest in the fund, only a hope of benefit and a right to be considered.

    That describes an object before any exercise of discretion. The trustees have already appointed £50,000 to her absolutely, which gives her a proprietary interest in that sum.

    Ruled out by: Last month the trustees executed a deed of appointment appointing £50,000 of capital to her absolutely, so she is no longer a mere object as to that sum.

    • Gartside v IRC [1968] AC 553 — An object of a discretionary trust has no proprietary interest in the fund before the discretion is exercised.
  • C
    Surface reading

    She has no equitable interest until the trustees actually pay the appointed sum to her.

    The appointment, once validly made by deed, vests the equitable interest in the appointed sum; payment is merely the trustees' subsequent duty.

    • Gartside v IRC [1968] AC 553 — It is the exercise of the discretion, not payment, that confers an interest on the object.
  • E
    Adjacent rule

    She and her adult siblings are together absolutely entitled and may require the trustees to distribute the fund.

    The trustees may add future grandchildren to the class, so the objects are not all ascertained and the children cannot collectively bring the trust to an end.

    • Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115 — Beneficiaries who are all ascertained, of full age and capacity and together absolutely entitled may direct the trustees to transfer the trust property.

Read with this question