Question 4
Knowing receiptMediumA trustee of a family trust asked his personal assistant to help him with a purchase. He told her that £60,000 would arrive in her personal current account and that she should forward it to a car dealer. The money duly arrived. Her bank statement showed the payment as coming from 'the Ashwood Trust — client account', and she recognised the name of the trust for which her employer acted as trustee. She thought it odd, but asked no questions. Two days later she transferred the whole £60,000 to the dealer, who delivered a car registered in the trustee's own name. She kept none of the money and she received nothing for her trouble beyond her ordinary monthly salary. The trustee has now moved abroad and cannot be traced. The trust deed contained no power to apply trust money for a trustee's personal use. The beneficiaries are the trustee's two nieces, both minors, represented by their mother. They wish to recover the £60,000.
Which of the following best describes whether the assistant is liable to the beneficiaries in knowing receipt?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer A
Correct answer
She is not liable, because she received the money as the trustee's agent and not for her own benefit.
Knowing receipt requires beneficial receipt: an agent who takes the money and passes it straight on as directed is not a knowing recipient.
The assistant's account was simply a conduit: she forwarded the entire £60,000 to the dealer and kept nothing, the car being registered in the trustee's name. Her suspicions are irrelevant because the beneficial receipt element fails; any claim against her lies in dishonest assistance.
Beneficial receipt is an essential element; a stranger who receives ministerially and pays the money on as directed is outside the claim, though accessory liability may arise.
- Bank of Credit and Commerce International (Overseas) Ltd v Akindele [2000] 4 All ER 221 — Recipient liability requires beneficial receipt of trust property plus knowledge making retention or dealing unconscionable.
- Agip (Africa) Ltd v Jackson [1990] Ch 265 — Receipt as agent, followed by payment on, is ministerial and not beneficial receipt.
Rule card
Knowing receipt: (i) property received in breach of trust; (ii) received for the recipient's own benefit; (iii) knowledge, while in receipt, making it unconscionable to retain or deal with it. Ministerial receipt by an agent does not satisfy (ii).
Why the other options fail
- BRight outcome, wrong reason
She is not liable, because she no longer holds the money and cannot restore it.
Right outcome, wrong reason: knowing receipt is a personal claim for value, so parting with the money is not in itself an answer where the recipient knew while holding it.
- Bank of Credit and Commerce International (Overseas) Ltd v Akindele [2000] 4 All ER 221 — Knowing receipt imposes personal liability for the value received; it does not depend on the recipient still holding the property.
- CRight outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative
She is liable, because she recognised the trust's name, suspected the payment was wrong and deliberately asked no questions.
Her state of knowledge would satisfy the unconscionability element, but the claim also requires receipt for her own benefit, which is absent.
Ruled out by: She kept none of the money and the car was registered in the trustee's own name, so however culpable her silence, she never received the funds for her own benefit.
- Bank of Credit and Commerce International (Overseas) Ltd v Akindele [2000] 4 All ER 221 — Knowledge making retention unconscionable is one element only; beneficial receipt must also be established.
- DAdjacent rule
She is liable, because she gave no consideration for the £60,000 she received.
Absence of consideration does not convert a ministerial receipt into a beneficial one; she took nothing for herself.
- Agip (Africa) Ltd v Jackson [1990] Ch 265 — An agent who receives and pays on trust money does not receive it for his own benefit, whether or not he gives value.
- ESurface reading
She is liable, because the whole of the £60,000 passed through a bank account held in her own name.
Receipt into her own account is not receipt for her own benefit; the beneficial element is missing because she held and paid on as directed.
- Agip (Africa) Ltd v Jackson [1990] Ch 265 — Receipt in a ministerial capacity, even into the agent's own account, does not amount to beneficial receipt.