Question 5
The nature of equitable remedies and the availability of tracing in equityEasierA trustee holds £60,000 on trust for two children. He withdraws £40,000 of that money and pays it into his personal current account, which already held £10,000 of his own savings. He then buys shares for £12,000 from that account and loses the remaining £38,000 at a casino, leaving the account empty.
What is the best advice to the beneficiaries as to a claim in respect of the shares?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer B
Correct answer
The beneficiaries may assert a proprietary claim to the shares, because the trustee cannot say that the surviving asset was bought with his own money when the rest of the account has been dissipated.
A trustee bought shares from an account mixing trust and personal money and dissipated the rest; the beneficiaries can trace into the shares.
On Re Oatway, a trustee who spends part of a mixed fund on an identifiable asset and dissipates the balance cannot claim the asset as his own; the beneficiaries may trace into the shares and may select the tracing rule most favourable to them.
Where a trustee buys an asset from a mixed account and dissipates the remainder, equity allows the beneficiaries to trace into the surviving asset; the beneficiaries may choose whichever tracing rule produces the best result for them.
- Re Oatway [1903] 2 Ch 356 — Beneficiaries may trace into an asset purchased from a mixed account where the balance has been dissipated.
- Re Hallett's Estate (1880) 13 Ch D 696 — The presumption that a trustee spends his own money first operates against the trustee.
Rule card
Mixed account (trust + trustee): the beneficiaries may cherry-pick between the Hallett presumption (own money spent first) and Re Oatway (charge on the surviving asset), whichever gives the better result.
Why the other options fail
- AAdjacent rule
The trustee's own £10,000 was spent first, so only £2,000 of the shares is trust property.
First-in-first-out is a rule for allocating between competing innocent contributors to an account, not between a trust and the wrongdoing trustee.
- Devaynes v Noble (Clayton's Case) (1816) 1 Mer 572 — In an active current account, withdrawals may be attributed to payments in on a first-in-first-out basis as between innocent claimants.
- CAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
The shares belong to the trustee, who is presumed to have spent his own money on the purchase first.
The Hallett presumption that a trustee spends his own money first cannot be used to defeat the beneficiaries where the balance has been dissipated; the presumption operates against the trustee, not in his favour.
Ruled out by: The remainder of the account was lost at the casino, leaving nothing; the presumption that the trustee spent his own money first cannot be used to give him the surviving shares.
- Re Hallett's Estate (1880) 13 Ch D 696 — A trustee who mixes trust money with his own is presumed to spend his own money first, a presumption applied against the wrongdoing trustee.
- DAdjacent rule
The claim is limited to the lowest balance in the account, which is nil.
The lowest intermediate balance rule caps a claim against the surviving balance of an account; it does not defeat a claim to an asset already purchased out of the account.
- Roscoe (James) (Bolton) Ltd v Winder [1915] 1 Ch 62 — A claim against a mixed account is limited to the lowest intermediate balance reached.
- ESurface reading
No proprietary claim lies, because mixing the trust money with the trustee's own money destroyed the equitable interest.
Mixing does not defeat the equitable interest; equity's tracing rules exist precisely to identify trust value in and out of mixed funds.
- Foskett v McKeown [2001] 1 AC 102 — Equitable tracing permits beneficiaries to identify trust value in substitute assets, including where trust money has been mixed.