FLK2, Sessions 1 and 2 · Requirement to keep and maintain accurate records in client ledgers, including requirement to carry out reconciliation of client accounts and to keep a record of bills to include

SQE1 Solicitors Accounts question: Submission, reduction and payment of bills including the VAT element

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 4

Submission, reduction and payment of bills including the VAT elementEasierEthics

A solicitor acts for a client in a boundary dispute. At the outset the solicitor gave the client a written estimate of £1,500 plus VAT for the work up to trial preparation, and the client paid £5,000 generally on account of costs. Three weeks ago the firm delivered a bill for professional charges of £2,000 plus VAT of £400, and transferred £2,400 from the client bank account to the business bank account. That sum remains in the firm's business bank account. The firm has since accounted to HMRC for the VAT on the bill in its quarterly return. The client has complained that the charges greatly exceed the estimate and that no revised estimate was ever given. The supervising partner accepts that the charges were excessive and decides to reduce the profit costs by £500, with a corresponding reduction of £100 in the VAT. The matter is continuing and further work is anticipated.

What should the firm now do in respect of the £600?

Show the answer and explanation
A

Correct answer

Return the £600 to the client account promptly and record the reduction on the business side of the client ledger.

When a delivered bill is reduced, the excess already transferred to the business account becomes client money and must be returned promptly, with the reduction of charges and VAT recorded on the business side of the client ledger.

The firm's entitlement to the £2,400 rested on the bill. Once the partner reduced the charges by £500 and the VAT by £100, the firm holds £600 to which it is not entitled; that is client money and rule 2.3 requires prompt payment into the client account. The reduction is recorded on the business side of the client ledger, reversing the profit costs and HMRC entries. Acting in the client's best interests also requires the firm to deal with the complaint about the estimate and repay the money without delay.

On reduction of the bill the firm is no longer entitled to the £600; it is money held for the client and must be paid promptly into the client account, the reduction of both profit costs and VAT being recorded on the business side of the client ledger against the profit costs and HMRC accounts.

  • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 2.3 — Client money must be paid promptly into a client account unless one of the listed exceptions applies.
  • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 8.1(a)(ii) — Bills of costs and non-client money transactions are recorded on the business side of the client ledger account.
  • SRA Principles, Principle 7 — A solicitor must act in the best interests of each client.

Rule card

Reduce bill → reverse the excess profit costs and VAT on the business side of the client ledger → the overheld sum is client money → pay it promptly into the client account.

Why the other options fail

  • B
    Right outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative

    Retain the £600 in the business account, showing a credit balance on the client ledger business side.

    A credit balance on the business side of a client ledger is the classic indicator that client money is being held outside the client account; the entries must reflect that the £600 is now the client's money and it must be moved.

    Ruled out by: The client had paid £5,000 generally on account, and the £600 ceased on reduction to be the firm's money; leaving it in the business account as a credit balance on the business side means client money is held outside the client account.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 8.1(a) — Client money is recorded on the client side of the ledger and non-client money on the business side, so the ledger must show the true character of the money.
  • C
    Outdated law

    Withdraw the delivered bill, deliver a fresh bill for the reduced amount, and return the £600 only after the client approves it.

    A firm may reduce a bill it has delivered and record the reduction; making repayment of money that is now the client's conditional on the client's approval of a new bill is not in the client's best interests.

    • SRA Principles, Principle 7 — A solicitor must act in the best interests of each client.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    Return only the £500 profit costs element, as the VAT has already been paid over to HMRC.

    A reduction in professional charges carries with it a reduction in the VAT charged on them; the firm adjusts its VAT account by a credit note and the full £600 belongs to the client.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 8.1(a)(ii) — Bills of costs are recorded on the business side of the client ledger, so a reduced bill requires reduction of both the charges and the VAT recorded there.
  • E
    Surface reading

    Retain the £600 in the business account on account of the further costs which are already anticipated in this continuing matter.

    Money held generally on account of future costs is client money; it cannot be left sitting in the business account merely because more work is expected.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 2.3 — Client money must be paid promptly into a client account unless an exception applies.

Read with this question