FLK2, Sessions 1 and 2 · Requirement to keep and maintain accurate records in client ledgers, including requirement to carry out reconciliation of client accounts and to keep a record of bills to include

SQE1 Solicitors Accounts question: Disbursements using the agency and principal methods

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 5

Disbursements using the agency and principal methodsMedium

A VAT-registered firm acts for a client in a contested probate claim. Counsel's fee note is addressed to the firm and states fees of £2,000 plus VAT at 20% of £400. The firm treats counsel's fees on the principal method. The firm holds £5,000 of client money for this client. The firm pays counsel £2,400 today from its business bank account. No bill of costs has yet been delivered to the client.

What entry falls to be made on the client ledger account when the payment to counsel is recorded?

Show the answer and explanation
C

Correct answer

£2,000, debited to the business side of the client ledger.

On the principal method the payment of counsel's fee is split: the full payment on the cash account, the VAT on the HMRC account, and the VAT-exclusive amount on the business side of the client ledger.

The firm treats counsel as supplying it, so the £400 VAT is the firm's input tax recorded on the HMRC account, and £2,000 is debited to the business side of the client's ledger as a payment made from business money on the client's behalf. The VAT will be charged on to the client when the firm bills, on a VAT invoice covering its own charges and the disbursement.

On the principal method the whole £2,400 goes through the cash account, the £400 VAT is recorded on the HMRC account as input tax, and the VAT-exclusive £2,000 is debited to the business side of the client ledger.

  • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 8.1(a)(ii) — All receipts and payments which are not client money are recorded on the business side of the client ledger account.
  • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 8.1 — Accurate, contemporaneous and chronological records must be kept of the transactions on each client's matter.

Rule card

Principal method: cash account, whole payment; HMRC account, the VAT; client ledger business side, the VAT-exclusive amount.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Right outcome, wrong reason

    £400, debited to the client ledger business side.

    This reverses the entries: it is the VAT that goes to the HMRC account and the VAT-exclusive fee that is charged to the client ledger.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 8.1(a)(ii) — The business side of the client ledger records the firm's payments on the client's behalf that are not client money.
  • B
    Surface reading

    £1,666.67, debited to the business side of the client ledger account.

    This extracts VAT from £2,400 as though that were a VAT-inclusive sum. The fee note already separates the fee of £2,000 from VAT of £400.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 8.1 — Records must be accurate, so the ledger must record the figures shown by the fee note.
  • D
    Outdated law

    Nil; the payment is recorded only on the cash account and the HMRC account.

    Disbursements are recorded on the client ledger when they are paid, not when the bill is delivered; a payment made on the client's behalf must appear on that client's ledger.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 8.1(a) — The client ledger must record all receipts and payments relating to the client's matter, on the appropriate side.
  • E
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    £2,400, debited in full to the business side of the client ledger account.

    Debiting the whole VAT-inclusive sum to the ledger is the agency method treatment, used where the fee note is treated as addressed to the client; here the firm has adopted the principal method.

    Ruled out by: The firm treats counsel's fees on the principal method, so the VAT is separated out to the HMRC account rather than debited to the client ledger with the fee.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 8.1(a)(ii) — Payments which are not client money are recorded on the business side of the client ledger account, the amount recorded depending on the treatment adopted.

Read with this question