FLK2, Sessions 1 and 2 · Client account

SQE1 Solicitors Accounts question: Obligation not to use client account to provide banking facilities

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 3

Obligation not to use client account to provide banking facilitiesMedium

A solicitor acted for a client on the sale of the client's shares in a private company. The sale completed last month and the firm holds the £50,000 balance of the sale proceeds in its client bank account. The client, who is abroad for three months, asks the firm to keep the money and to use it to pay the monthly invoices of the builder renovating the client's home and the client's monthly credit card bills. The client confirms these instructions in writing. No further legal work is required on the share sale.

Which of the following best describes how the firm should respond to the client's request?

Show the answer and explanation
B

Correct answer

The firm should refuse, because the payments would not be in respect of the delivery of regulated services.

Holding the completed sale proceeds and paying the client's personal bills from them would be providing banking facilities through the client account, which rule 3.3 forbids.

Rule 3.3 requires every transfer or withdrawal from a client account to be in respect of the delivery of regulated services. The share sale is complete and no further legal work is required, so the builder's invoices and credit card bills are unconnected with any regulated service; the firm should refuse and return the balance.

The legal work is finished and the proposed payments are the client's personal outgoings. Making them would use the client account to provide banking facilities, contrary to rule 3.3; the balance should be returned to the client.

  • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 3.3 — You must not use a client account to provide banking facilities to clients or third parties; payments into, and transfers or withdrawals from, a client account must be in respect of the delivery by you of regulated services.
  • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 5.1 — Client money is withdrawn only for the purpose for which it is held, on instructions, or on the SRA's prior written authorisation or in prescribed circumstances.

Rule card

Rule 3.3: no banking facilities through a client account — every payment in, transfer or withdrawal must relate to regulated services the firm is delivering. Client instructions (rule 5.1(b)) and sufficiency of funds (rule 5.3) do not override this.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Surface reading

    The firm should cease acting and report the client to the SRA.

    A request that the firm must decline is not itself a ground for reporting the client; the proper course under rule 3.3 is to refuse and return the money.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 3.3 — The response required is that the client account is not used for payments unconnected with regulated services.
  • C
    Right outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative

    The firm may make the payments, because the client has given written instructions and the money is held for that client.

    Instructions under rule 5.1(b) permit a withdrawal that is otherwise proper; they cannot authorise use of the client account as a banking facility prohibited by rule 3.3.

    Ruled out by: No further legal work is required on the share sale, so even a written instruction cannot make the payments referable to the delivery of regulated services.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 5.1(b) — Client money may be withdrawn following receipt of instructions from the client, subject to the other requirements of the Rules.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    The firm may make the payments, because sufficient funds are held in the client bank account on behalf of that client.

    Rule 5.3 is a limit on withdrawals, not an authority to make them. It does not displace rule 3.3, which requires payments to relate to the delivery of regulated services.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 5.3 — Client money may only be withdrawn if sufficient funds are held for that specific client; this is a restriction, not a permission.
  • E
    Surface reading

    The firm may retain the money in a separate designated deposit client account and account to the client for the interest earned.

    The prohibition in rule 3.3 applies to any client account, however designated. Accounting for interest does not make the retention and payments referable to regulated services.

    • SRA Accounts Rules, rule 3.3 — The prohibition on providing banking facilities applies to the use of a client account generally.

Read with this question