FLK2, Session 2 · Matters that do not require express planning permission

SQE1 Property Law and Practice question: Matters that do not require express planning permission

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 4

Matters that do not require express planning permissionMedium

A solicitor acts for the buyer of a high street shop. The buyer wants to use part of the premises as a children's day nursery and wants certainty about the planning position before exchange. The buyer intends to start the new use immediately on completion. The local search result has not yet arrived. A planning officer has telephoned asking what the buyer intends.

What is the most appropriate step for the solicitor to advise the buyer to take?

Show the answer and explanation
E

Correct answer

Apply to the local planning authority, before the use begins, for a certificate of lawfulness of proposed use or development.

Where it is unclear whether a proposed change of use is development, or whether it is already permitted, the buyer can resolve the doubt in advance by applying for a certificate of lawfulness of proposed use or development.

Section 192 allows an application before the change is begun; the authority must issue the certificate if satisfied the proposal is not development or is permitted development, and must otherwise refuse, which gives the buyer the certainty it wants before exchange.

Where it is doubtful whether a proposed change amounts to development or falls within the GPDO, the statutory route is an application for a certificate made before the change is commenced.

  • Town and Country Planning Act 1990, s 192 — A certificate of lawfulness of proposed use or development may be applied for before the works or change are commenced; the authority must issue it if satisfied the proposal would not constitute development or would be permitted development.

Rule card

Doubt about whether express permission is needed: apply under s 192 TCPA 1990 for a certificate of lawfulness before commencing. Always check the current GPDO and the local search for an Article 4 direction.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Surface reading

    Ask the planning officer to confirm in writing that express planning permission is not required.

    Informal advice or written confirmation from a planning officer does not bind the local planning authority and cannot prevent future enforcement action; only a formal certificate of lawfulness or express planning permission provides legal certainty.

    • Western Fish Products Ltd v Penwith District Council [1981] 2 All ER 204 — Informal assurances given by planning officers do not bind the planning authority and do not create an estoppel against planning enforcement.
  • B
    Adjacent rule

    Begin the use on completion and apply for a certificate of lawfulness afterwards.

    An application for a certificate of lawfulness of proposed use or development is made before the proposed change is commenced; beginning first exposes the buyer to enforcement action.

    • Town and Country Planning Act 1990, s 192 — The application is made before the works or change of use are commenced, specifying the proposed works or change.
  • C
    Surface readingClosest alternative

    Rely on the GPDO, which automatically permits the change without any application.

    Before relying on the GPDO the solicitor must check the current version and confirm, through the local search, that no Article 4 direction negates the concession; here the search result has not arrived.

    Ruled out by: The local search result has not yet arrived, so it is not known whether an Article 4 direction has removed the GPDO concession.

    • General Permitted Development Order (GPDO) — The GPDO grants planning permission automatically for specified development, but its effect can be excluded by an Article 4 direction.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    Apply for express planning permission, as that is the only way to obtain certainty.

    An application is unnecessary where the change may not be development, or may be permitted development; the statutory route to certainty is an application for a certificate.

    • Town and Country Planning Act 1990, s 192 — A person may apply to the local planning authority before works or a change of use are begun for a certificate that the proposal would be lawful.

Read with this question