Question 3
Statutory definition of “Development”HarderA woman owns the freehold of a retail unit with an open yard at the rear. For many years the yard has been used by her staff for parking cars while working in the shop. She has agreed to grant a ten-year lease of the yard to the builders' merchant next door, which will use it for the open storage of scaffolding and sand. No buildings will be erected and no surfacing or other works will be carried out. Her staff will park in the street instead, and the yard will no longer serve the shop. The title contains no restrictive covenants.
Which of the following best describes whether planning permission is required for the arrangement?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer E
Correct answer
Yes, because using the yard for open storage is a material change in the use of the land; the grant of the lease is not itself development.
No works are involved, but the yard's use changes materially, from parking ancillary to the shop to open storage for a separate business; the lease itself is irrelevant to s 55.
Section 55 catches a material change in the use of buildings or other land, so the absence of any works does not matter and open land is within the definition. The yard ceases to serve the shop and is used for the open storage of materials by a different business, which is a material change of use and therefore development requiring permission under s 57(1). The grant of the lease is a dealing with an interest in land and is not development.
The yard passes from staff car parking ancillary to the shop to open storage for a separate business, and will no longer serve the shop: that is a material change in the use of land under s 55, requiring permission under s 57(1).
- Town and Country Planning Act 1990, s 55 — Development means the carrying out of building, engineering, mining or other operations in, on, over or under land, or the making of any material change in the use of any buildings or other land.
- Town and Country Planning Act 1990, s 57(1) — Planning permission is required for carrying out any development of land.
Rule card
Material change of use of 'any buildings or other land' is development (TCPA 1990, s 55), whether or not any works are carried out. Dealings with legal estates are not development.
Why the other options fail
- ARight outcome, wrong reason
Yes, because the grant of the lease creates a separate legal estate in the yard, which is development in itself.
Right outcome, wrong basis: dealing with interests in land is not within s 55. What makes this development is the change in the actual use of the yard.
- Town and Country Planning Act 1990, s 55 — Development consists of operations or a material change of use, not of dealings with legal estates or interests.
- BAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
No, because the yard has always been used in connection with the retail unit, so its use by an adjoining owner for storage cannot be a material change.
A long-standing use establishes the existing lawful use, but it does not prevent a later change from being material.
Ruled out by: The scenario states that the staff will park in the street and the yard will no longer serve the shop, so the storage use by the adjoining merchant is not a continuation of the yard's ancillary use.
- Town and Country Planning Act 1990, s 55 — It is the making of a material change in the use of land, judged against its existing use, that constitutes development.
- CSurface reading
No, because development requires building, engineering, mining or other operations, and no works will be carried out at the yard.
Operations are only the first limb of s 55; the making of a material change of use is development even where no works at all are undertaken.
- Town and Country Planning Act 1990, s 55 — Development includes the making of any material change in the use of any buildings or other land as well as operations.
- DSurface reading
No, because the change of use limb is concerned with buildings, and the yard is open land with no building on it.
Section 55 refers to a material change in the use of any buildings or other land, so open land is within the definition.
- Town and Country Planning Act 1990, s 55 — Development includes the making of any material change in the use of any buildings or other land.