FLK2, Session 2 · Enforcement: time limits and the range of local planning authority’s enforcement powers

SQE1 Property Law and Practice question: Enforcement: time limits and the range of local planning authority’s enforcement powers

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 5

Enforcement: time limits and the range of local planning authority’s enforcement powersMedium

A local planning authority in England has received complaints from neighbours, who have written three times, about a car repair business operating from a yard. The yard has the benefit of a 2015 planning permission for open storage, granted subject to conditions about hours of working and the siting of vehicles. The authority's officer needs to know what activities are being carried on at the yard, when the repair business started, and whether the conditions attached to the 2015 permission are being complied with, before deciding whether it is expedient to take enforcement action and, if so, on what basis. The owner has ignored two letters from the authority, refuses the officer entry and will not say when the repair business began, although nothing suggests that he has misled the authority about the use. The officer's report records no immediate harm requiring urgent intervention, and notes that the repairs may have been carried on for several years.

What is the appropriate next step for the authority?

Show the answer and explanation
C

Correct answer

Serve a planning contravention notice requiring the owner to provide information about the activities on the land.

Where the authority lacks information, the investigative power is the planning contravention notice.

The officer needs to know what activities are carried on, when they began and whether the 2015 conditions are observed. A planning contravention notice compels exactly that information, and the owner has refused entry.

A planning contravention notice requires the recipient to give information about operations, uses or activities on the land and about matters relating to conditions attached to a permission, which is exactly what the authority lacks.

  • Town and Country Planning Act 1990, Part VII — A planning contravention notice requires the recipient to provide information about operations, use or activities on the land and any matter relating to conditions attached to a planning permission.

Rule card

Investigation: right of entry or planning contravention notice. Then enforcement notice (with stop notice), breach of condition notice for condition breaches, temporary stop notice for urgency, injunction in extreme cases.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Surface reading

    Issue an enforcement notice now specifying the breach and the steps required, leaving the owner to appeal if the use is lawful.

    An enforcement notice must specify the alleged breach and the steps to remedy it, and be expedient; the authority cannot do that until it knows what is happening and since when.

    • Town and Country Planning Act 1990, Part VII — An enforcement notice may be issued where it appears there has been a breach and it is expedient to do so, and must specify the alleged breach and the steps to be taken.
  • B
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    Serve a temporary stop notice to halt the repairs while further enquiries are made.

    A temporary stop notice buys 28 days where activity must be halted at once; it yields no information and the report records no urgency.

    Ruled out by: The officer's report records no immediate harm requiring urgent intervention, and a temporary stop notice would produce none of the information the authority needs.

    • Town and Country Planning Act 1990, Part VII — A temporary stop notice is effective for 28 days only and is used to halt a breach while matters are investigated.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    Serve a breach of condition notice requiring compliance with the conditions attached to the 2015 permission.

    A breach of condition notice requires an existing condition to have been breached; the authority does not yet know whether the conditions are being broken and needs to investigate first.

    • Town and Country Planning Act 1990, Part VII — A breach of condition notice may be served where planning permission for development has been granted subject to conditions and any of the conditions has not been complied with.
  • E
    Civil-law intuition

    Apply to the court for an injunction restraining the use.

    An injunction is discretionary and reserved for extreme cases where it is expedient and necessary; that cannot be shown before the facts are known.

    • Town and Country Planning Act 1990, Part VII — An injunction to restrain an actual or apprehended breach of planning control is a discretionary remedy requiring the authority to show it is expedient and necessary.

Read with this question