FLK1, Session 1 · The regulatory role of the SRA

SQE1 Legal Services question: Other regulated providers of legal services

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 4

Other regulated providers of legal servicesMedium

A company authorised and regulated by the SRA provides legal services to consumers. Its managing director, who is a solicitor, wishes to widen the range of work offered by using outside providers and asks for advice on five proposals. Under the first, the transfer of a registered freehold house and the application to register it would be handled by a licensed conveyancer regulated by the Council for Licensed Conveyancers. Under the second, advocacy at a county court trial would be undertaken by a chartered legal executive authorised by CILEx Regulation to exercise rights of audience in the county court. Under the third, wills would be drafted by an unregulated will-writing business. Under the fourth, a personal injury claim in the High Court would be conducted by a costs lawyer. Under the fifth, applications for grants of probate would be made on executors' behalf by an unregulated estate administration business. All five providers would work under the solicitor's supervision.

How many of the five proposals could lawfully be carried out by the provider named?

Show the answer and explanation
B

Correct answer

Three, because drafting a will is not a reserved legal activity and the conveyancer and the legal executive are each authorised for the work proposed.

Three proposals are lawful: the licensed conveyancer's work, the legal executive's advocacy and the unregulated will drafting.

Will drafting is not a reserved legal activity, so anyone may do it. The licensed conveyancer and the chartered legal executive are each authorised by their approved regulator for the reserved activity proposed. Conducting a High Court personal injury claim and applying for grants of probate are reserved activities for which a costs lawyer and an unregulated estate administration business respectively are not authorised.

The first, second and third proposals are lawful; conducting the High Court claim and applying for grants of probate are reserved activities which those providers are not authorised to carry on.

  • Legal Services Act 2007, s.13 — Only an authorised or exempt person is entitled to carry on a reserved legal activity.

Rule card

Reserved legal activities may be carried on only by an authorised or exempt person (Legal Services Act 2007, ss.12–14); authorisation may come from any approved regulator, not only the SRA, but only for the activities covered.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Surface reading

    Five, because reserved activities may be carried on by anyone working under a solicitor's supervision.

    Supervision does not confer entitlement; carrying on a reserved activity without authorisation is an offence.

    • Legal Services Act 2007, s.14 — It is an offence for a person to carry on a reserved legal activity unless entitled to do so.
  • C
    Adjacent rule

    Two, since drafting a will for a client is a reserved instrument activity.

    Drafting a will is not within the list of reserved legal activities, so an unregulated business may do it.

    • Legal Services Act 2007, s.12 — The reserved legal activities are those listed in the section; will drafting is not among them.
  • D
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    Four, because a costs lawyer is authorised to conduct any form of civil litigation.

    A costs lawyer's authorisation does not extend to conducting a personal injury claim in the High Court.

    Ruled out by: The fourth proposal involves a costs lawyer conducting a personal injury claim in the High Court, which falls outside that provider's authorisation.

    • Legal Services Act 2007, s.13 — Entitlement depends on being authorised in relation to the particular reserved activity.
  • E
    Surface reading

    One, because only a person authorised by the SRA may carry on reserved legal activities.

    Other approved regulators, such as the Council for Licensed Conveyancers and CILEx Regulation, also authorise persons for reserved activities.

    • Legal Services Act 2007, s.13 — A person authorised by any relevant approved regulator is entitled to carry on the reserved activity in question.

Read with this question