Question 5
The Equality Act 2010HarderA firm's only offices are on the first floor of a building with no lift, and its lease forbids structural alterations. A wheelchair user telephones asking for an appointment to make a will. The receptionist, following the firm's standing practice, tells him the firm cannot see clients anywhere other than its offices, and suggests he instructs a firm nearby.
Which of the following best describes the firm's position under the Equality Act 2010?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer A
Correct answer
The firm has failed to take such steps as are reasonable to avoid the disadvantage.
A service provider whose premises substantially disadvantage a disabled person must take such steps as are reasonable, and offering the service at another location is an obvious step.
The firm is a service provider subject to the anticipatory duty to make reasonable adjustments. The inaccessible first floor substantially disadvantages a wheelchair user, and because the firm refused to see clients anywhere else it has failed to take a step which was reasonably available.
As a service provider the firm owes an anticipatory duty to disabled people; where a physical feature causes substantial disadvantage it must take reasonable steps, and meeting the client elsewhere was plainly available.
- Equality Act 2010, s 20 — Requires reasonable steps to avoid substantial disadvantage caused by a practice or a physical feature.
- Equality Act 2010, s 29 — Applies the duty to those providing services to the public.
Rule card
Services: reasonable adjustments duty is anticipatory, owed to disabled people at large, and requires reasonable steps (including alternative methods of delivery) where a physical feature or practice causes substantial disadvantage. No justification defence.
Why the other options fail
- BSurface reading
There is no breach, because the client can instruct another firm nearby.
The availability of a competitor does not discharge a service provider's own duty to the disabled person requiring its services.
- Equality Act 2010, s 29 — The duty to make reasonable adjustments is owed by each person concerned with the provision of services to the public.
- CAdjacent rule
The firm has directly discriminated, because a client who was not disabled would have been given an appointment at the offices.
The refusal results from the inaccessibility of the premises and the firm's blanket practice, not from treating him less favourably because of disability; the adjustments duty is the apt analysis.
- Equality Act 2010, s 13 — Direct discrimination occurs where a person treats another less favourably because of a protected characteristic.
- DAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
The firm has indirectly discriminated by applying a practice which puts disabled persons at a particular disadvantage.
Indirect discrimination is capable of justification as a proportionate means to a legitimate aim; the disadvantage here falls squarely within the separate and unjustifiable adjustments duty.
Ruled out by: The receptionist told him the firm cannot see clients anywhere other than its offices, so a reasonable alternative step existed; the adjustments duty, which cannot be justified away, governs rather than indirect discrimination.
- Equality Act 2010, s 19 — Indirect discrimination arises from a provision, criterion or practice which puts persons sharing a protected characteristic at a particular disadvantage and which cannot be shown to be a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
- ESurface reading
There is no breach, because the terms of the firm's lease prevent it from altering the premises.
The lease may make structural alteration unreasonable, but the duty is to take whatever steps are reasonable, such as providing the service by another means.
- Equality Act 2010, s 20 — The duty is to take such steps as it is reasonable to have to take to avoid the substantial disadvantage.