Question 3
Circumstances encountered in the course of practice where suspicion of money laundering should be reported in accordance with the legislationMediumA solicitor is conducting due diligence on the sale of a company. Reviewing the management accounts, she notices that the trading income shown is substantially greater than the figures in the corporation tax returns for the same periods. The discrepancy relates to undeclared trading income of around £400,000. The figures were supplied directly by the company's external accountant. The solicitor is suspicious but cannot be sure the discrepancy is deliberate, and is considering putting the discrepancy to the finance director before doing anything else.
Which of the following best describes the solicitor's obligations?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer A
Correct answer
She must make a disclosure, because she has grounds to suspect that another person is engaged in money laundering and the information came to her in the course of business in the regulated sector.
Suspicion arising from information received in the regulated sector triggers the s.330 duty to disclose.
The solicitor need not be certain: s.330 bites where information coming to her in the course of a business in the regulated sector gives grounds for knowing or suspecting money laundering, and the retained proceeds of tax evasion are criminal property.
Section 330 is engaged by suspicion, or reasonable grounds for suspicion, arising from information coming to the solicitor in the course of a business in the regulated sector.
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s.330 — Failure to disclose in the regulated sector where there are grounds to suspect money laundering is an offence.
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s.340 — Criminal property includes the benefit of criminal conduct such as tax evasion.
Rule card
s.330: regulated sector + suspicion or reasonable grounds + no required disclosure as soon as practicable = offence. Privileged circumstances exception is narrow; do not seek explanations that risk tipping off.
Why the other options fail
- BAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
She need not report, because the information came to her in privileged circumstances while advising the client.
The privileged circumstances exception is narrow and does not cover accounting records supplied by a third-party accountant for due diligence.
Ruled out by: The figures were supplied directly by the company's external accountant, not communicated to the solicitor for the purpose of giving legal advice, so the privileged circumstances exception does not apply.
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s.330(6) — There is no offence where the information came to the professional legal adviser in privileged circumstances.
- CAdjacent rule
She should put the discrepancy to the finance director and report only if no satisfactory explanation is given.
Seeking an explanation once suspicion has arisen risks tipping off and delays a disclosure that must be made as soon as practicable.
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s.333A — Disclosing information likely to prejudice an investigation is an offence.
- DSurface reading
She need not report unless and until she knows that the discrepancy results from deliberate tax evasion.
Knowledge is not required; suspicion, or reasonable grounds for suspicion, suffices.
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s.330 — The offence arises where the person knows or suspects, or has reasonable grounds to do so.
- ERight outcome, wrong reason
She need not report, because unpaid tax is not criminal property for money laundering purposes.
Retained proceeds of tax evasion constitute criminal property, so suspicion of evasion is reportable.
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s.340 — Criminal property is property constituting or representing a benefit from criminal conduct, which includes the proceeds of tax evasion.