Question 2
Fixed feesMediumA firm advertises a fixed fee of £1,200 plus VAT for conducting an unfair dismissal claim in the employment tribunal. A dismissed sales manager instructs the firm on that basis. The engagement letter describes the fixed fee as "all-inclusive" for the work listed in a schedule, which covers preparation of the claim, one day of tribunal hearing and routine correspondence; work outside the schedule is to be charged at £250 per hour by separate agreement. Three months later the employer amends its response to allege gross misconduct, six additional witnesses are to be called and the hearing is relisted for three days instead of one. The fee earner estimates a further 30 hours of work. The firm writes to the client saying that it cannot continue on the original basis and proposes to re-bill the whole matter at £250 per hour.
Which of the following best describes the firm's position on charging?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer C
Correct answer
It may charge hourly for work outside the schedule if the client agrees, but the fixed fee continues to cover the scheduled work.
A fixed fee is a contractual price for defined work; additional work outside that definition can be charged only by agreement, and the client must be kept informed about costs.
The engagement letter fixed the price of the scheduled work and provided for other work to be charged at £250 per hour by separate agreement. The firm may therefore seek the client's agreement to charge hourly for the extra hearing days and witness work, but the scheduled work remains covered by the fixed fee, and the client must be given information about the likely overall cost as the matter progresses.
The retainer priced the scheduled work at the fixed fee and allowed other work to be charged hourly by separate agreement; the client must agree the variation and be given information about the likely overall cost.
- SRA Code of Conduct for Firms, para 7.1(c) — Client information standards, including costs information, apply to the firm.
- SRA Principle 7 — Duty to act in the best interests of each client.
Rule card
Fixed fee = price for a defined scope. Work outside the scope may be charged only if the client agrees a variation; work inside the scope stays at the fixed fee. Keep the client informed about costs throughout.
Why the other options fail
- AAdjacent rule
Its only proper course is to cease acting, since it cannot perform the retainer at the agreed fixed fee.
Ceasing to act is not the only option: the firm may seek the client's agreement to charge for work outside the schedule, as the engagement letter envisaged.
- SRA Principle 7 — Acting in the client's best interests includes exploring an agreed variation before abandoning the matter.
- BRight outcome, wrong reason
It may switch to hourly charging unilaterally, because the work now greatly exceeds what was contemplated.
The basis of charging is contractual; it cannot be altered without the client's agreement, whatever the increase in work.
- SRA Principle 7 — A solicitor must act in the best interests of each client.
- DOutdated lawClosest alternative
It may re-bill the entire matter at £250 per hour, provided the client is given written notice of the revised charging basis before the hearing.
Notice is not agreement; work already covered by the fixed fee remains priced at that fee unless the client agrees otherwise.
Ruled out by: The engagement letter required work outside the schedule to be charged 'by separate agreement', so notice of a revised rate is not enough and the scheduled work cannot be re-billed.
- SRA Principle 5 — A solicitor must act with integrity.
- ESurface reading
It is bound by the all-inclusive fixed fee and can charge nothing further, whatever the additional work.
The fee was all-inclusive only for the scheduled work; the engagement letter expressly contemplated charging for work outside the schedule by separate agreement.
- SRA Code of Conduct for Firms, para 7.1(c) — The client information standards, including those on pricing and costs information, apply to the firm.