Question 1
Private retainerMediumA solicitor is instructed privately by a man in a boundary dispute with his neighbour. The client care letter gives an estimate of £3,000 plus VAT for work up to and including a mediation, charged at hourly rates, and asks for £1,000 on account. The dispute becomes more complicated: the neighbour instructs an expert surveyor and the mediation is adjourned twice. The solicitor carries on working and says nothing further about costs until the matter settles seven months later, and she then delivers a bill for £7,000 plus VAT. The client, who paid the £1,000 on account, complains about the bill for £7,000 plus VAT and says he was never warned the estimate would be exceeded.
Which of the following best describes the solicitor's position in relation to professional conduct?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer E
Correct answer
The solicitor should have updated the client as soon as it was likely that the estimate would be exceeded.
An estimate is not a cap, but the client must be told promptly when it is likely to be exceeded.
The complications, the expert surveyor and the two adjournments made it clear that the £3,000 estimate would be exceeded. The solicitor's silence for seven months breached the duty to give the client the best possible information about the likely overall cost as the matter progressed.
The duty is to give the best possible information about likely overall cost throughout the retainer, so the client can decide whether to continue.
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 8.7 — Duty to give and update costs information.
Rule card
Estimate exceeded: update the client as soon as it becomes apparent, before the extra costs are run up. The bill may still be assessed, but that does not cure the conduct breach.
Why the other options fail
- ARight outcome, wrong reason
Once the bill has been delivered the solicitor may sue for the whole sum, so the earlier absence of costs information does not matter.
The right to sue on a delivered bill is a civil matter and does not remove the conduct breach in failing to update the client.
- Solicitors Act 1974, s.69 — No action may be brought to recover costs until one month after delivery of a bill.
- BSurface reading
An estimate creates no obligation at all, so the client must simply pay the full £7,000 plus VAT as billed.
Although not a quotation, an estimate carries a duty to keep the client informed as costs develop, which was not done here.
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 8.7 — Costs information must be given at the outset and updated as the matter progresses.
- CAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
No conduct issue arises because the client may seek assessment of the bill.
The statutory right to assessment addresses the amount of the bill; it does not answer the separate conduct duty to keep the client informed about costs.
Ruled out by: The client's complaint is that he was never warned the estimate would be exceeded, which is a conduct failure distinct from the amount of the bill.
- Solicitors Act 1974, s.70 — A client may apply for assessment of a solicitor's bill.
- DCivil-law intuition
The estimate is legally binding as a fixed fee, and the client need pay no more than £3,000 plus VAT in total.
An estimate given with hourly rates is not a fixed fee; it must, however, be kept under review and the client updated.
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 8.7 — Clients must receive the best possible information about likely overall cost; an estimate is information, not a cap agreed as a price.