FLK2, Session 1 · Co-ownership and Trusts

SQE1 Land Law question: Severance of joint tenancies

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 3

Severance of joint tenanciesMedium

Two women own a flat, both registered as proprietors, holding the beneficial interest as joint tenants. They had earlier discussed severance and could not agree. One woman then made a will leaving 'my share in the flat' to her nephew, and posted a letter to the other stating that she wished to sever the joint tenancy in equity immediately. The other woman refused to discuss the letter and never replied to it.

Which of the following best describes the effect of these events?

Show the answer and explanation
D

Correct answer

The letter severed the joint tenancy in equity, so the beneficial interest is now held as a tenancy in common in equal shares.

Unilateral written notice severs the equitable joint tenancy; the legal joint tenancy cannot be severed and the will is irrelevant.

The letter was a written notice of a desire to sever given to the other joint tenant, which s.36(2) makes effective without reply or agreement; the beneficial interest becomes a tenancy in common in equal shares.

Written notice of a desire to sever, given to the other joint tenant, is effective under s.36(2); the legal estate remains a joint tenancy.

  • Law of Property Act 1925, s.36(2) — Written notice of a desire to sever severs the equitable joint tenancy; the legal joint tenancy cannot be severed.

Rule card

s.36(2) LPA 1925: no severance of legal joint tenancy; equitable severance by written notice, or by acts effectual to sever personal estate.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Adjacent rule

    Nothing was severed, because the women never reached agreement on severance.

    Mutual agreement is one method of severance, but unilateral written notice under s.36(2) is another and does not require agreement.

    • Law of Property Act 1925, s.36(2) — Notice in writing by one joint tenant of a desire to sever is effectual to sever in equity.
  • B
    Surface reading

    The letter did not sever the joint tenancy, because the other joint tenant never acknowledged it.

    Section 36(2) requires only that written notice be given to the other joint tenants; no acknowledgement or consent is needed.

    • Law of Property Act 1925, s.36(2) — A joint tenant desiring to sever shall give the other joint tenants notice in writing of such desire.
  • C
    Adjacent rule

    The will severed the joint tenancy, because it shows an intention to deal with a distinct share.

    A will takes effect only on death, by which time survivorship has already operated; it cannot sever.

    • Law of Property Act 1925, s.36(2) — Severance in equity requires notice in writing or acts effectual to sever a tenancy in personal estate during life.
  • E
    Right outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative

    The legal and equitable joint tenancies were both severed, so the women now hold as tenants in common throughout.

    No severance of a joint tenancy of a legal estate so as to create a tenancy in common is permissible; severance operates only in equity.

    Ruled out by: Both women are registered as proprietors of the legal estate, which s.36(2) prevents from being held as a tenancy in common.

    • Law of Property Act 1925, s.36(2) — No severance of a joint tenancy of a legal estate, so as to create a tenancy in common in land, is permissible.

Read with this question