FLK2, Session 1 · Proprietary Rights

SQE1 Land Law question: Rules for the passing of the benefit and burden of freehold covenants

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 4

Rules for the passing of the benefit and burden of freehold covenantsHarder

Thirty years ago a seller sold a plot and the buyer covenanted, in the transfer, not to erect any building over two storeys. The covenant was made 'with the covenantee and her successors in title', the covenantee being described simply as owner of 'the adjoining estate', which the deed did not identify or define. A notice was entered on the burdened title. The estate has since changed hands twice, with no mention of the covenant in either transfer. The present owner of the plot, who bought knowing of the notice, has begun a three-storey extension. The current estate owner wishes to enforce the covenant.

Which of the following best identifies the principal obstacle to the current estate owner's claim?

Show the answer and explanation
E

Correct answer

The deed does not identify the dominant land, so the benefit cannot be shown to have been annexed to the estate.

The claimant's difficulty is proving the benefit passed: the deed identifies no dominant land.

Enforcement in equity needs the burden to run and the benefit to have passed. Annexation, express or under s.78 LPA 1925, requires the land intended to be benefited to be identifiable. The deed refers only to an undefined 'adjoining estate', and no assignment was taken on either later sale, so the current estate owner cannot establish title to sue.

Annexation, whether express or statutory, requires the land benefited to be identifiable; a reference to an undefined 'adjoining estate' does not suffice.

  • Law of Property Act 1925, s.78 — A covenant relating to any land of the covenantee is deemed made with the covenantee and successors in title to that land.
  • Tulk v Moxhay — The covenant must have been made to benefit dominant land retained by the covenantee.

Rule card

Burden in equity: Tulk v Moxhay (negative, taken for retained dominant land, touching and concerning, notice/registration). Benefit in equity: annexation, assignment or building scheme — annexation needs identifiable dominant land.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Civil-law intuition

    The benefit cannot pass to a later owner of the estate at all, because covenants bind only the original parties.

    The benefit can pass by annexation, assignment or scheme of development; the difficulty is the absence of identified dominant land.

    • Tulk v Moxhay — The benefit of a restrictive covenant may pass in equity to successors of the covenantee.
  • B
    Surface reading

    There is no obstacle, since the covenant is negative and the present owner of the plot bought with notice of it.

    Notice and negativity address the burden; the claimant must separately establish that the benefit has passed to him.

    • Tulk v Moxhay — Enforcement in equity requires both that the burden runs and that the claimant has the benefit.
  • C
    Right outcome, wrong reason

    The chain of express assignments of the benefit was broken on the two intervening sales of the estate.

    No assignment was ever made, so there was no chain to break; the prior problem is that no dominant land was identified.

    • Tulk v Moxhay — The benefit may pass by express assignment made on each disposition of the dominant land.
  • D
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    Section 78 LPA 1925 annexes the benefit automatically, so the current estate owner's title to sue is unimpeachable.

    Statutory annexation still requires the dominant land to be identifiable from the deed or surrounding circumstances.

    Ruled out by: Section 78 annexation cannot help because the deed described the covenantee only as owner of 'the adjoining estate', which it did not identify or define.

    • Law of Property Act 1925, s.78 — A covenant relating to land of the covenantee is deemed made with the covenantee and successors in title.

Read with this question