Question 2
Interests that override registration and interests that need to be protected on the registerMediumA buyer has completed the purchase of a farm comprising a farmhouse, fields and a barn. The farm was registered freehold land with title absolute, and the seller was the sole registered proprietor. The buyer paid the full price to the seller and is now registered as proprietor. The charges register contained a notice of a covenant restricting use of the land to agriculture. Since taking possession the buyer has discovered the following. The seller's sibling contributed to the purchase of the farm in 2009 and claims a 25% beneficial share; the sibling lives in Spain and has never occupied the farm. The seller's cohabitant contributed substantially to the mortgage instalments over ten years, claims a beneficial share and has lived at the farmhouse throughout; two bedrooms are filled with her possessions and she was there on the day of completion. A neighbour has used the farm track daily since a written agreement signed in 2018, which was never executed as a deed and never noted on the register; the track shows visible tyre marks. Finally, a lease of the barn for ten years was granted by deed in 2022 and was never registered; that tenant has not yet taken possession, being engaged on another site.
Which of these interests, if any, binds the buyer as an interest that overrides the registered disposition?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer D
Correct answer
The cohabitant's beneficial interest, because she was in obvious actual occupation of the farmhouse at completion.
An unprotected beneficial interest overrides a registered disposition where its owner is in obvious actual occupation and the money is not paid to two trustees.
The cohabitant has a beneficial interest under a trust and was living at the farmhouse at completion, with two bedrooms of possessions — obvious actual occupation. As the seller was the sole registered proprietor, payment of the price to him could not overreach her interest, so it overrides.
She has a proprietary interest under a trust and was in obvious actual occupation; the price was paid to a sole trustee, so there was no overreaching.
- Land Registration Act 2002, s.29(2)(a)(ii) — An interest falling within a paragraph of Schedule 3 retains its priority against a registered disposition for valuable consideration.
- Land Registration Act 2002, Sch 3, para 2 — The interest of a person in actual occupation overrides, broadly where the occupation is obvious.
Rule card
Registered land: Sch 3 para 1 — leases of seven years or less; para 2 — proprietary interest plus obvious actual occupation; para 3 — certain legal easements and profits. Interests already noted in the register take priority under s.29(2)(a)(i), not as overriding interests.
Why the other options fail
- ARight outcome, wrong reason
The restrictive covenant, because it burdens the land and was disclosed on the title.
The covenant binds the buyer, but because its priority is protected by a notice in the register, not as an interest that overrides.
- Land Registration Act 2002, s.29(2)(a)(i) — The priority of an interest is protected if it is the subject of a notice in the register.
- BAdjacent rule
The neighbour's right over the farm track, because it has been used openly since 2018.
The paragraph covering easements that override applies to legal easements; a right granted by signed writing without a deed is equitable and needed a notice.
- Land Registration Act 2002, Sch 3, para 3 — Certain legal easements and profits override a registered disposition; equitable easements require protection by notice.
- COutdated lawClosest alternative
The barn lease, because a lease granted by deed takes effect at law whether or not it is registered.
A lease of more than seven years is a registrable disposition and must be completed by registration to be legal; only leases of seven years or less override automatically.
Ruled out by: The barn lease was for ten years, exceeding seven, so it required registration to be legal, and the tenant has not taken possession.
- Land Registration Act 2002, Sch 3, para 1 — Leases granted for a term not exceeding seven years override a registered disposition.
- Land Registration Act 2002, s.27 — A registrable disposition, including the grant of a lease exceeding seven years, does not operate at law until completed by registration.
- ESurface reading
The sibling's 25% beneficial share, because a beneficial interest under a trust cannot be defeated by a sale.
An unprotected beneficial interest gains overriding status only through actual occupation; the sibling has never occupied the farm.
- Land Registration Act 2002, Sch 3, para 2 — Only the interest of a person in actual occupation can override a registered disposition on this ground.