FLK2, Session 1 · Leases

SQE1 Land Law question: Privity of contract and privity of estate

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 5

Privity of contract and privity of estateHarder

A head landlord granted a 15-year lease of a warehouse in 2019. The lease contains a tenant covenant not to use the premises for retail sales. Last year the tenant sublet the whole of the warehouse for three years. The sub-tenant was given a copy of the headlease before completing, and the sublease contains a covenant by the sub-tenant with the tenant to observe the covenants in the headlease. The sub-tenant has opened a discount shop in the warehouse. The head landlord wants the retail use stopped quickly and does not want to lose the tenant's rent.

What is the head landlord's best course of action against the sub-tenant?

Show the answer and explanation
B

Correct answer

Seek an injunction against the sub-tenant, since a restrictive covenant binds any occupier of the premises.

A head landlord has no privity with a sub-tenant, but a restrictive covenant in the headlease is enforceable directly against any occupier of the demised premises.

The covenant against retail use is negative. The head landlord may therefore enforce it against the sub-tenant as occupier, and in equity the sub-tenant, who was given a copy of the headlease before completing, took with notice. An injunction stops the use without forfeiting the headlease and losing the rent.

The user covenant is restrictive, and the head landlord is entitled to enforce a restrictive covenant against any owner or occupier of the demised premises; equity enforces such covenants against a sub-tenant who took with notice of the headlease.

  • Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, s.3(5) — A landlord may enforce a restrictive covenant against any owner or occupier of the demised premises.
  • Tulk v Moxhay — Restrictive covenants bind those taking the land with notice of them.

Rule card

Sub-tenants: no privity of contract or estate with the head landlord, so positive covenants cannot be enforced against them; restrictive covenants can be, against any owner or occupier and against a sub-tenant with notice.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Right outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative

    Claim damages from the tenant only, because there is no privity of contract or estate with the sub-tenant.

    It is true that no privity exists, but a restrictive covenant is nevertheless directly enforceable against an occupier, and the sub-tenant here had notice of the headlease.

    Ruled out by: The covenant is restrictive and the sub-tenant was given a copy of the headlease before completing, so the absence of privity does not prevent enforcement against it.

    • Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, s.3(5) — Restrictive covenants may be enforced by the landlord against any owner or occupier of the demised premises, irrespective of privity.
  • C
    Adjacent rule

    Claim damages from the sub-tenant, because privity of estate exists between the head landlord and the sub-tenant.

    A sublease, even of the whole, creates no estate relationship between the head landlord and the sub-tenant: the burden of the tenant covenants passes only to an assignee of the tenancy.

    • Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, s.3 — The burden of the tenant covenants passes on an assignment of the tenancy, not on the grant of a sublease.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    Forfeit the headlease; the sub-tenant has no right to relief.

    Forfeiture would destroy the tenant's rent, and in any event an underlessee may apply to the court for relief and a vesting order.

    • Law of Property Act 1925, s.146(4) — An underlessee may apply to the court for an order vesting the premises in it where the lessor is proceeding to enforce a right of re-entry.
  • E
    Civil-law intuition

    Sue the sub-tenant on its covenant in the sublease to observe the covenants in the headlease.

    That covenant is given to the mesne tenant; the head landlord is not a party and the sublease does not purport to confer an enforceable benefit on it, so this is not the route to a swift remedy.

    • Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999, s.1 — A third party may enforce a term only where the contract expressly so provides or the term purports to confer a benefit on it and it is identified in the contract.

Read with this question