FLK2, Session 1 · Nature of Land

SQE1 Land Law question: Different ways in which land can be held

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 1

Different ways in which land can be heldMedium

Three sisters bought a registered freehold house in 2015 for £300,000, each contributing £100,000. The transfer declared that they held the house as beneficial joint tenants. In 2019 the eldest sister moved abroad and, by deed, assigned her whole beneficial interest in the house to a friend in return for £110,000. She did not tell her sisters about the assignment and no application was made to HM Land Registry in respect of it. In 2021 all three sisters discussed selling the house; the middle sister obtained a valuation, the youngest refused to sell, and nothing came of the discussions. In 2023 the middle sister made a will leaving 'my one-third share in the house' to her son, and told her solicitor that she wished the youngest sister to have nothing. The middle sister died last month. The youngest sister remains in occupation, pays the outgoings and has spent £8,000 on a new roof. The register still names all three sisters as proprietors and has not been altered.

Which of the following best describes the beneficial ownership of the house?

Show the answer and explanation
A

Correct answer

The friend holds one third as tenant in common; the surviving sister holds the remaining two thirds.

An assignment by deed of a joint tenant's beneficial interest severs that share; a will cannot sever, so survivorship operates on death.

The eldest sister's assignment was an act operating on her own share and severed one third, which the friend holds as tenant in common. The remaining two sisters continued as joint tenants of two thirds, so on the middle sister's death the youngest took that two thirds by survivorship and the will was ineffective.

The assignment by deed was an act by the eldest sister operating on her own share, severing one third for the friend. The other two remained joint tenants of two thirds, which passed to the survivor on the middle sister's death, her will being ineffective to sever.

  • Williams v Hensman — A joint tenancy in equity may be severed by an act of one joint tenant operating on his own share, by mutual agreement or by a course of dealing.
  • Law of Property Act 1925, s.1(6) — A legal estate cannot subsist in an undivided share, so severance affects the equitable interest only.

Rule card

Severance in equity: act operating on own share, mutual agreement, or course of dealing, all inter vivos. A will never severs; survivorship beats the will.

Why the other options fail

  • B
    Surface reading

    The assignment is ineffective because the other sisters did not consent, so the surviving sister is solely entitled.

    A joint tenant may deal with her own beneficial interest without the agreement of the others; their ignorance affects neither the validity of the assignment nor the resulting severance.

    • Williams v Hensman — A joint tenant may sever by alienating his own share, no concurrence of the other joint tenants being required.
  • C
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    The friend, the son and the surviving sister each hold one third as tenants in common, the deceased sister's will passing her share.

    Severance must occur during the joint tenant's lifetime; a will takes effect only at death, by which time survivorship has already operated.

    Ruled out by: The middle sister's disposition was made by will, which takes effect only on death, after survivorship has already operated.

    • Williams v Hensman — Severance of a joint tenancy must be effected inter vivos by an act operating on the share.
  • D
    Right outcome, wrong reason

    The friend, the son and the surviving sister each hold one third as tenants in common, the abortive negotiations having severed the joint tenancy.

    Negotiations which come to nothing, one sister refusing to sell, do not show a common intention that the joint tenancy should be treated as held in shares.

    • Burgess v Rawnsley — A course of dealing severs a joint tenancy only where it shows that the parties treated their interests as held in shares.
  • E
    Surface reading

    The surviving sister is solely entitled in equity, an assignment of an equitable interest not severing a joint tenancy.

    An assignment of a joint tenant's beneficial interest is the paradigm act operating on her own share and severs that share.

    • Williams v Hensman — An alienation by one joint tenant of his interest severs the joint tenancy as to that share.

Read with this question