FLK1, Session 1 · Disclosure and inspection

SQE1 Dispute Resolution question: Orders for disclosure

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 3

Orders for disclosureMedium

A claimant on the multi-track received the defendant's list of documents in Form N265. It referred to no emails, although the defendant's staff corresponded by email throughout the events in dispute. The emails sit on servers operated by an outside IT contractor, which the defendant is entitled to have copied. The claimant wrote explaining fully why the emails should be disclosed. The defendant did not reply.

Which order should the claimant now apply for?

Show the answer and explanation
B

Correct answer

Specific disclosure, including an order that a search be carried out.

A party who considers the other side's disclosure inadequate applies under rule 31.12 for specific disclosure, which can require a search.

The claimant has already made the written request explaining why the emails should be disclosed and has had no reply. Rule 31.12(2) permits an order that specified documents or classes be disclosed, that a search be carried out to the stated extent, and that any documents so located be disclosed.

Where a party considers another party's disclosure inadequate, rule 31.12 allows an order that specified documents or classes be disclosed, that a search be carried out to a stated extent, and that documents found be disclosed.

  • CPR 31.12(2) — Sets out what an order for specific disclosure may require, including a search to the extent stated in the order.
  • PD 31A para 5 — Guidance on applications for specific disclosure following an unanswered written request.

Rule card

Inadequate disclosure → written request → application under r 31.12 for specific disclosure (disclose specified documents / search / disclose what the search finds). Specific inspection is for documents already referred to.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Adjacent rule

    An order requiring the defendant to permit inspection within seven days of the claimant's written notice.

    The seven-day period operates only where a party has a right to inspect a document that has been disclosed; nothing has been disclosed here.

    • CPR 31.15 — A party with a right to inspect must give written notice, and the disclosing party must permit inspection not more than seven days after receipt.
  • C
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    Specific inspection of the emails, as documents referred to in the defendant's list of documents.

    Specific inspection concerns a document referred to in rule 31.3(2); these emails have not been disclosed at all, so disclosure, not inspection, is the issue.

    Ruled out by: The defendant's list referred to no emails at all, so there is nothing already disclosed for an inspection order to bite on.

    • CPR 31.12 — An order for specific inspection is an order that a party permit inspection of a document referred to in rule 31.3(2).
  • D
    Surface reading

    An order that the defendant serve a further list of documents verified by a disclosure statement.

    Rule 31.10(4) governs the content of a list; the rule providing a remedy for inadequate disclosure is rule 31.12.

    • CPR 31.10(4) — The list must indicate documents in respect of which a right or duty to withhold inspection is claimed and documents no longer in the party's control.
  • E
    Right outcome, wrong reason

    An order for disclosure against the IT contractor, as the person who actually holds the emails.

    The defendant is entitled to have the emails copied, so they are within the defendant's control and no order against the contractor is needed.

    • CPR 31.8 — A party has control of a document where there is a right to inspect or take copies of it.

Read with this question