Question 2
Interim paymentsMediumA cyclist was struck by a lorry and suffered multiple fractures. Proceedings claiming £250,000 have been issued in the County Court and served. The lorry owner's insurers wrote before proceedings admitting liability in full but disputing the amount of the claim; an acknowledgment of service has been filed indicating an intention to defend as to quantum only, and the defence is not due for another two weeks. The insurers made a voluntary payment of £15,000 last year. The cyclist has since paid £8,000 in medical experts' fees and £2,000 on account of her solicitor's charges. She is unable to work, needs to adapt her bathroom and to fund a course of private physiotherapy, and the trial is unlikely to take place for at least 18 months. Her solicitor is considering an application for an interim payment.
Which of the following best describes the cyclist's position as to obtaining an interim payment?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer A
Correct answer
An interim payment may be ordered now, but only on account of damages and not the costs already incurred.
An interim payment is available before trial but is a payment on account of damages only; costs are excluded by statute.
Liability is admitted and proceedings are pending, so an application may be made now; but the sum ordered can only be on account of the damages the defendant may be held liable to pay, and the £8,000 experts' fees and £2,000 of solicitor's charges are costs, which the statutory definition excludes.
An interim payment is a payment on account of damages, debt or other sum which the defendant may be held liable to pay, expressly excluding costs.
- County Courts Act 1984, s.50(1) and (5) — Rules of court may empower the court to order an interim payment, being a payment on account of any damages, debt or other sum (excluding any costs) which the party may be held liable to pay if final judgment is given against it.
- Senior Courts Act 1981, s.32(5) — The equivalent High Court definition likewise excludes costs.
Rule card
Interim payment = payment on account of damages/debt/other sum, excluding costs; available in High Court (SCA 1981 s.32) and County Court (CCA 1984 s.50).
Why the other options fail
- BAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
The £8,000 of experts' fees may be included, as it forms part of the sum the defendant may be held liable to pay.
The statutory definition of an interim payment expressly excludes costs, so incurred disbursements and solicitor's charges cannot be the subject of an interim payment.
Ruled out by: The £8,000 paid to medical experts is costs, and the statutory definition of an interim payment expressly excludes costs.
- County Courts Act 1984, s.50(5) — "Interim payment" means a payment on account of any damages, debt or other sum excluding any costs.
- CAdjacent rule
The application must be made in the High Court, as the County Court has no power to order interim payments.
The County Court has an equivalent statutory power, exercisable under rules of court, so proceedings need not be transferred.
- County Courts Act 1984, s.50(1) — Provision may be made by rules of court enabling the County Court to order a party to make an interim payment.
- DSurface reading
No interim payment may be ordered until judgment on liability has been given, because the sum payable is not yet established.
The whole purpose of the interim payment jurisdiction is to order a payment on account of a sum the party may be held liable to pay if judgment is later given in the other party's favour.
- County Courts Act 1984, s.50(5) — An interim payment is a payment on account of a sum which the party may be held liable to pay if a final judgment or order is later given in favour of the other party.
- EAdjacent rule
No application may be made until the defendant has filed its defence.
The jurisdiction depends on proceedings being on foot and the prescribed conditions being met, not on a defence having been filed.
- Senior Courts Act 1981, s.32(1) — Rules of court may enable the court, in such circumstances as may be prescribed, to order an interim payment as regards proceedings pending in the court.