Question 4
Inter-partes costs orders (interim and final)MediumOn 10 April a claimant obtained judgment at trial in a multi-track claim, with an order that the defendant pay the claimant's costs, to be subject to detailed assessment if not agreed. The sealed order was served on the defendant's solicitors on 20 April and the defendant paid £25,000 on account of costs within 14 days of the judgment. The parties then negotiated the amount of the claimant's costs without success until August. The defendant's solicitors have asked how long they will have to respond once the bill arrives. The claimant's solicitors now wish to know their own deadline for starting detailed assessment proceedings.
By when must the claimant commence detailed assessment proceedings?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer D
Correct answer
Within three months of the date of the judgment which gave the right to detailed assessment
Detailed assessment must be commenced within three months of the date of the judgment or order giving the right to it.
Judgment with the costs order was given on 10 April, so the notice of commencement with the bill must be served within three months of that date. Service of the sealed order, the payment on account and the failed negotiations do not alter the trigger date.
Detailed assessment proceedings are commenced by serving a notice of commencement with a copy of the bill, and that must be done within three months of the date of the judgment or order, here 10 April.
- CPR 47.7 — Three months from the date of the judgment or order to commence detailed assessment.
Rule card
CPR 47.7: commence within three months of the judgment or order. CPR 47.9: points of dispute within 21 days of the notice of commencement. CPR 47.8: on default, the paying party may apply to compel commencement and interest may be disallowed.
Why the other options fail
- AAdjacent rule
Within 21 days of the date of the judgment
Twenty-one days is the period for the paying party to serve points of dispute after service of the notice of commencement, not the period for commencing assessment.
- CPR 47.9 — Points of dispute must be served within 21 days after service of the notice of commencement.
- BSurface reading
Within three months of the date on which the payment on account of costs was made
The period for commencing detailed assessment runs from the date of the judgment or order giving the right to detailed assessment under CPR 47.7, not from the date an interim payment on account is made.
- CPR 47.7 — Detailed assessment proceedings must be commenced within three months after the date of the judgment, direction, order, award or other determination.
- CSurface reading
Within three months of the parties' failure to agree the amount of costs
Negotiations do not extend or restart the period; the trigger is the judgment or order itself.
- CPR 47.7 — Time runs from the date of the judgment or order giving the right to detailed assessment.
- ESurface readingClosest alternative
Within three months of the date on which the sealed order was served on the defendant's solicitors
The period runs from the date of the judgment or order giving the right to detailed assessment, not from service of the sealed order.
Ruled out by: Time runs from the date of the judgment, 10 April, not from service of the sealed order on 20 April.
- CPR 47.7 — Detailed assessment proceedings must be commenced within three months of the date of the judgment, direction, order, award or other determination.