Question 1
Time limits for responding to a claimHarderA construction company issued a claim form in the High Court against an engineering consultancy for £400,000 for negligent design. The claim form stated that the particulars of claim would follow, and the claim form alone was deemed served on the consultancy on 2 May. The consultancy's solicitor filed an acknowledgement of service at court on 10 May, indicating an intention to defend the whole claim. The particulars of claim, running to 40 pages with technical appendices, were served on 1 June. On 20 June the solicitors for the two parties agreed in an exchange of emails that the consultancy should have a further 14 days in which to file its defence, and the consultancy's solicitor wrote to the court the same day notifying it of the agreement. Neither party has applied to the court for any order.
By when must the consultancy file its defence?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer D
Correct answer
13 July, being 28 days after service of the particulars plus the agreed extension.
Time ran from service of the particulars of claim; an acknowledgement of service gave 28 days, and the parties' 14-day agreed extension was within the permitted maximum.
28 days from service of the particulars on 1 June expired on 29 June; the agreed 14-day extension, notified to the court in writing, extends the deadline to 13 July.
28 days from 1 June gives 29 June; the validly agreed 14-day extension, of which the court was notified, takes the date to 13 July.
- CPR r 15.5 — The parties may agree to extend the time for service of the defence for no more than 28 days, the defendant notifying the court in writing.
Rule card
Particulars to follow: respond after particulars served. Defence 14 days (or 28 with acknowledgement of service); parties may agree up to 28 days more with written notice to the court.
Why the other options fail
- ASurface reading
16 May, being 14 days after deemed service of the claim form.
Where the claim form indicates that the particulars will follow, the defendant need not respond until the particulars are served.
- CPR r 10.3 — Where the claimant serves the particulars of claim with the claim form, the defendant has 14 days after service of the claim form to respond.
- BRight outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative
13 July, but only if the court makes an order approving the parties' agreement.
An agreed extension of up to 28 days requires only written notification to the court, not an order.
Ruled out by: The consultancy's solicitor wrote to the court notifying it of the agreement, which is all that is required; no court order is needed for an agreed extension of 14 days.
- CPR r 15.5 — Where the parties agree to extend the period of time for filing a defence, the defendant must notify the court in writing.
- CCivil-law intuition
29 June, because the time for filing a defence cannot be extended by agreement between the parties.
The parties may agree an extension of up to 28 days provided the court is notified in writing, which happened here.
- CPR r 15.5 — Where the parties agree to extend the period of time for filing a defence, the defendant must notify the court in writing.
- EAdjacent rule
15 June, since the acknowledgement of service was filed before the particulars of claim were served.
An acknowledgement of service filed under Part 10 attracts the 28-day period; nothing turns on its being filed before the particulars.
- CPR r 15.4(b) — If the defendant files an acknowledgement of service under Part 10, the defence must be filed 28 days after service of the particulars of claim.