FLK1, Session 1 · Enforcement of money judgments

SQE1 Dispute Resolution question: Oral examinationobtaining information from judgmentdebtor

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 5

Oral examinationobtaining information from judgmentdebtorMedium

Judgment was entered against an individual on 4 March for £18,000, the order requiring payment within 28 days. Nothing has been paid, and the judgment creditor has as yet taken no enforcement step of any kind. On 20 March the judgment debtor wrote disputing the amount of the judgment but has made no application to the court. The judgment creditor's file note records that the judgment will remain enforceable for years to come. Today is 15 April.

When may the judgment creditor apply for an order requiring the judgment debtor to attend court to provide information?

Show the answer and explanation
E

Correct answer

Now, because the 28 days specified for payment in the judgment order have expired and the debt remains unpaid.

A judgment creditor may apply for an order to obtain information once the period fixed for compliance in the order has expired and the debt remains unpaid.

The order fixed 28 days from 4 March for compliance, which expired on 1 April. Nothing having been paid, the debt is now presently owed and unsatisfied, entitling the creditor to apply under CPR Part 71.

The 28 days allowed for payment expired on 1 April without payment. Under CPR 71.2(1), the creditor may now apply for an order requiring the debtor to attend court to provide information, stating the amount presently owed.

  • CPR 71.2(1) — Authorises an application for an order requiring a judgment debtor to attend court to provide information to enable enforcement.
  • CPR 40.11 — Specifies that the judgment debtor must comply within 14 days unless the order specifies a different date.

Rule card

A judgment debtor must pay within 14 days unless the order specifies a different date (CPR 40.11). Once the date for compliance passes unsatisfied, the creditor may apply without notice under CPR 71.2(1) for an order requiring the debtor to attend court to provide information.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Adjacent rule

    From 18 March, because the standard time for compliance with a money judgment under CPR 40.11 is 14 days from entry of judgment.

    CPR 40.11 sets 14 days as the default compliance time only where the judgment or order does not specify a different date; here the order expressly allowed 28 days, so no default arose on 18 March.

    • CPR 40.11 — A party must comply with a judgment for the payment of money within 14 days, unless the judgment specifies a different date for compliance.
  • B
    Adjacent rule

    Now, but only by an application on notice to the judgment debtor giving at least 14 days' notice of the application.

    Under CPR 71.2(2)(a), an application for an order requiring a judgment debtor to attend court to provide information may be made without notice.

    • CPR 71.2(2)(a) — An application under paragraph (1) may be made without notice.
  • C
    Adjacent rule

    Only after the court determines the debtor's dispute, because an active dispute suspends enforcement of the judgment.

    Writing to dispute the judgment amount does not operate as a stay under CPR 40.11(c); in the absence of an order of the court staying the judgment, enforcement may proceed once the time for compliance has expired.

    • CPR 40.11(c) — A party must comply with a judgment for the payment of money unless the court has stayed the proceedings or judgment.
  • D
    Civil-law intuitionClosest alternative

    Immediately upon entry of judgment on 4 March, because a judgment debt is payable and enforceable as soon as judgment is entered.

    Because the order gave the debtor 28 days to pay, the judgment debt was not overdue on 4 March; enforcement steps and applications requiring disclosure of debt presently owed cannot precede the expiry of the compliance period.

    Ruled out by: The order explicitly gave 28 days for compliance, so the sum was not overdue or presently in default immediately upon entry on 4 March.

    • CPR 71.2(1) — The application notice must state the amount presently owed under the judgment or order.

Read with this question