FLK2, Session 2 · General defences

SQE1 Criminal Liability question: Self-defence/defence of another

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 3

Self-defence/defence of anotherMedium

A man runs a hardware shop on a high street. He lives in a flat above the shop, reached by a separate street door. Shortly before closing time, a customer becomes abusive about a refund, shouting and leaning across the counter with a clenched fist. The man, who has been threatened in the shop before, believes that the customer is about to punch him. There is an unlocked rear door a few feet behind him through which he could easily have left the shop. Instead, before the customer has touched him, the man picks up a heavy steel bar from a display and strikes him hard on the shoulder. The customer falls to the floor and lies still. Still frightened and acting on impulse in the seconds that follow, the man strikes him three more times on the head, fracturing his skull. The customer was not armed at any point. The man is charged with causing grievous bodily harm with intent and wishes to rely on self-defence.

Which of the following best describes whether the man can rely on self-defence?

Show the answer and explanation
C

Correct answer

Self-defence fails, because although he believed force was necessary, the degree of force he used was disproportionate in the circumstances.

Self-defence has a subjective limb (was force believed necessary?) and an objective limb (was the degree of force reasonable?). The second limb defeats this defendant.

He honestly believed force was necessary, so the first limb is satisfied, and neither the absence of retreat nor the pre-emptive nature of the first blow harms him. But three further blows to the head of an unarmed man lying still are disproportionate, and as the force was used in his shop rather than in a householder situation the test is disproportion, not gross disproportion.

Necessity is judged on the defendant's own belief, but the degree of force is assessed objectively: repeated blows to the head of an unarmed man already on the floor are disproportionate, and this is not a householder case.

  • Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008, s 76 — Consolidates the case law: necessity is judged subjectively, the degree of force objectively, with the gross disproportion test reserved for householder cases.
  • Criminal Law Act 1967, s 3(1) — Permits the use of such force as is reasonable in the prevention of crime.

Rule card

Self-defence: necessity judged on D's honest belief; degree of force judged objectively — disproportionate force is unreasonable (grossly disproportionate in householder cases). No duty to retreat; pre-emptive force allowed; heat of the moment taken into account.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Adjacent rule

    Self-defence fails, because he could have escaped through the rear door instead of using any force.

    There is no duty to retreat; the availability of an escape route is at most one circumstance in assessing reasonableness, not a bar to the defence.

    • Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008, s 76 — Consolidates the case law on self-defence, under which there is no duty to retreat and a defendant may act pre-emptively.
  • B
    Right outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative

    Self-defence succeeds, because allowance is made for his acting in the heat of the moment and his genuine belief that he was about to be attacked.

    Account is taken of the heat of the moment, but it does not convert disproportionate force into reasonable force; the objective limb must still be satisfied.

    Ruled out by: The heat-of-the-moment allowance does not displace the objective limb: he struck three further blows to the head of a customer who had fallen to the floor and was lying still.

    • Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008, s 76 — Account is taken of the fact that the defendant acted in the heat of the moment, but the degree of force must still be reasonable in the circumstances.
  • D
    Surface reading

    Self-defence fails, because he struck first, before the customer had made any physical contact with him.

    A defendant may act pre-emptively; striking first does not of itself defeat the defence.

    • Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008, s 76 — Self-defence includes pre-emptive strikes; the defendant need not wait to be struck.
  • E
    Adjacent rule

    Self-defence succeeds, because the force was not grossly disproportionate to the threat he faced.

    The gross disproportion test applies only in householder cases; force used behind the counter of a shop against a customer is judged by ordinary disproportion.

    • Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008, s 76 — Force is unreasonable if disproportionate, unless it is a householder case, where it is unreasonable only if grossly disproportionate.

Read with this question