FLK2, Session 2 · Definition of the offence

SQE1 Criminal Liability question: Actus reus

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 2

Actus reusMedium

A woman is employed as a lifeguard at a municipal swimming pool. Her contract of employment requires her to remain at the poolside and to keep the water under continuous observation throughout her shift. That morning she removed a sign warning that the far end of the pool was deep, because it had become dirty, and did not replace it. Twenty minutes before the end of her shift her mobile telephone rang. She left the poolside and went into the staff corridor to take a personal call, leaving the pool unsupervised. While she was away a nine-year-old boy, who had come to the pool with his father, got into difficulty at the deep end. The boy's father was sitting in the poolside café with his back to the water and did not notice. Another adult swimmer saw the boy struggling and did nothing. The woman returned after six minutes, saw the boy face down in the water, pulled him out and began mouth-to-mouth resuscitation. She stopped after two minutes because her shift had ended and a colleague had arrived. The boy died. The woman is charged with manslaughter by gross negligence.

Which of the following best explains whether the woman's failure to supervise the pool can satisfy the actus reus of the offence?

Show the answer and explanation
B

Correct answer

Yes, because her contract of employment placed her under a duty to supervise the swimmers.

An omission satisfies the actus reus where the defendant was under a legal duty to act; here the duty came from her contract of employment.

Her contract required her to remain at the poolside observing the water. Leaving the pool unsupervised was a breach of a contractual duty on which the safety of swimmers depended, so the omission can constitute the actus reus.

A duty to act may arise out of a contract, and breach of it can found the actus reus of manslaughter where others rely on its performance for their safety.

  • R v Pittwood (1902) 19 TLR 37 — A duty to act can arise from a contract of employment, and its breach can found criminal liability for an omission.

Rule card

Duties to act: statute; contract; special relationship; voluntary assumption of care; creation of a dangerous situation; public office.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Adjacent rule

    Yes, because she created the danger by removing the sign warning that the far end of the pool was deep.

    Removing the sign did not create the situation that killed the boy; the duty here derives from her employment, not from creation of a dangerous situation.

    • R v Miller [1983] 2 AC 161 — A defendant who creates a dangerous situation must take reasonable steps to counteract it once aware of it.
  • C
    Right outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative

    Yes, because she voluntarily assumed responsibility for the boy when she pulled him from the water and began resuscitation.

    Right outcome, wrong basis: the relevant omission is the failure to supervise, which preceded any assumption of care, and her duty already existed under her contract.

    Ruled out by: The omission charged is the six-minute failure to supervise, which happened before she touched the boy at all; her duty already arose from her contract of employment.

    • R v Stone and Dobinson [1977] QB 354 — A duty to act may arise where the defendant voluntarily assumes responsibility for a helpless person.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    No, because the law imposes no general duty to rescue a stranger.

    That is the general rule, illustrated by the bystander swimmer, but it yields where the defendant is under a recognised duty to act.

    • R v Smith (William) (1826) 2 C & P 449 — There is no general duty to act for the benefit of another; liability for omission requires a duty.
  • E
    Adjacent rule

    No, because a duty to act arises only where there is a special relationship, such as parent and child.

    A special relationship is one source of a duty but not the only one; contract, assumption of care and creation of danger also give rise to duties.

    • R v Gibbins and Proctor (1918) 13 Cr App R 134 — A parent's relationship with a child gives rise to a duty to act, breach of which may found homicide liability.

Read with this question