FLK2, Session 2 · Partial defences

SQE1 Criminal Liability question: Diminished responsibility

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 4

Diminished responsibilityMedium

A man is charged with murder and relies on diminished responsibility. The defence has served two psychiatric reports diagnosing a rare disorder not previously considered by the appellate courts. The judge accepts there is sufficient evidence to raise the issue. The prosecution's own expert disagrees with the defence experts about whether the man's ability to exercise self-control was weightily impaired. Counsel asks how the jury should be directed on proof.

Which statement correctly describes the burden and standard of proof?

Show the answer and explanation
E

Correct answer

The defence must prove on the balance of probabilities that the man's ability to exercise self-control was weightily impaired.

Diminished responsibility carries a defence burden, discharged on the balance of probabilities.

Section 2(2) of the Homicide Act 1957 requires the defence to prove the section; the civil standard applies, and the impairment must be weighty per R v Golds.

Section 2(2) places the burden on the defence, discharged on the balance of probabilities, and 'substantial' means important or weighty under R v Golds.

  • Homicide Act 1957, s.2(2) — The defence must prove diminished responsibility.
  • R v Golds [2016] UKSC 61 — 'Substantial' means important or weighty.

Rule card

Diminished responsibility: defence bears the burden (s.2(2) Homicide Act 1957), balance of probabilities. Loss of control: prosecution must disprove beyond reasonable doubt once the issue is properly raised (s.54(5) CJA 2009).

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Surface reading

    The defence cannot discharge any burden because the disorder has not previously been recognised by the appellate courts.

    Section 2(1)(a) requires a recognised medical condition, meaning recognised medically; previous judicial consideration is not required.

    • Homicide Act 1957, s.2(1)(a) — The abnormality of mental functioning must arise from a recognised medical condition.
  • B
    Adjacent ruleClosest alternative

    Once the issue is raised the jury must assume the section is satisfied unless the prosecution disproves it.

    That is the rule for loss of control in s.54(5) of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009, not for diminished responsibility.

    Ruled out by: The judge's ruling that there is sufficient evidence to raise the issue triggers the reverse burden only for loss of control under s.54(5); this man relies on diminished responsibility, where s.2(2) keeps the burden on the defence.

    • Coroners and Justice Act 2009, s.54(5) — For loss of control, the jury must assume the defence is satisfied unless the prosecution proves beyond reasonable doubt that it is not.
  • C
    Right outcome, wrong reason

    The defence must prove the elements of the section beyond reasonable doubt.

    Section 2(2) imposes a defence burden, but a defence burden is discharged on the balance of probabilities.

    • Homicide Act 1957, s.2(2) — The burden of proving the section rests on the defence.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    The prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that the man does not fall within the section.

    Section 2(2) of the Homicide Act 1957 places the burden on the defence; the reverse burden belongs to loss of control under s.54(5).

    • Homicide Act 1957, s.2(2) — It shall be for the defence to prove that the person charged is not liable to be convicted of murder by virtue of this section.

Read with this question