FLK2, Session 2 · Parties

SQE1 Criminal Liability question: Principal offender

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 5

Principal offenderMedium

A woman shares a flat with a colleague whom she blames for the loss of a promotion. She fills an empty capsule with a fatal dose of garden pesticide and puts it in the colleague's box of headache tablets. That evening a friend visits. The colleague complains of a headache, and the woman asks the friend to fetch 'her tablet' from the box in the kitchen. The friend, who knows nothing of the pesticide, chooses the capsule of her own accord, hands it to the colleague and watches her swallow it. Both the woman and the friend are in the room. The colleague dies within the hour.

Which of the following best describes the woman's liability for the colleague's death?

Show the answer and explanation
D

Correct answer

The woman is the principal offender, having acted through an innocent agent.

The woman used a person with no knowledge of the poison to administer it; she is the principal offender through an innocent agent.

The woman had the mens rea for murder and set in motion the events causing death; the friend, ignorant of the pesticide, committed no offence. The instigator is therefore the principal offender acting through an innocent agent, rather than a secondary party.

Where the actus reus is performed by a person who lacks mens rea and is innocent of any offence, the instigator who set the events in motion with the necessary mens rea is the principal offender through the doctrine of innocent agency.

  • R v Michael (1840) 9 C & P 356 — Death caused through an ignorant intermediary makes the instigator the principal offender.
  • Accessories and Abettors Act 1861, s.8 — Aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring the commission of an offence makes a person punishable as a principal offender.

Rule card

Identify the principal first. Where the person performing the acts is innocent of any offence, the instigator with mens rea is the principal through innocent agency; secondary liability under s.8 Accessories and Abettors Act 1861 is the analysis where the other party does commit the offence.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Adjacent rule

    The woman is a secondary party, because she counselled the friend to give the colleague the capsule.

    Secondary liability is derivative: it requires a principal offence. The friend, who knew nothing of the pesticide, has no mens rea, so there is no offence for the woman to have counselled; the law treats her as the principal.

    • Accessories and Abettors Act 1861, s.8 — A person who aids, abets, counsels or procures the commission of an offence is liable to be tried and punished as a principal offender.
  • B
    Adjacent rule

    The woman is not liable, because the friend's free and deliberate act broke the chain of causation.

    An intervening act relieves the defendant only where it is free, deliberate and informed. The friend did not know what the capsule contained, so her act was not informed and does not break the chain.

    • R v Kennedy (No 2) [2007] UKHL 38 — Only a free, deliberate and informed act of a third party breaks the chain of causation.
  • C
    Right outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative

    The woman is a secondary party who procured the offence, and is punishable as a principal offender.

    Procuring means taking steps to produce the commission of an offence by another. Here the other party committed no offence because she was innocent, so the better analysis is principal liability through an innocent agent, not procuring.

    Ruled out by: The friend knew nothing of the pesticide, so no principal offence was committed for the woman to procure; her liability is as principal through an innocent agent.

    • Attorney General's Reference (No 1 of 1975) [1975] QB 773 — To procure means to produce by endeavour, setting out to see that the offence happens.
  • E
    Surface reading

    The woman and the friend are joint principals, because both were present and both brought about the death.

    Joint principals are those who together perform the actus reus with the necessary mens rea. The friend had no mens rea at all, so she is not a principal, whether or not she was present.

    • SQE Criminal Law, 11.2 (Table 11.1) — Joint principals are two or more people who perform the actus reus of an offence together with the required mens rea.

Read with this question