FLK2, Session 2 · Specified criminal offences

SQE1 Criminal Liability question: Murder

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 1

MurderMedium

A man climbs onto a footbridge over a motorway at night carrying a paving slab. Angry about a recent driving ban, he says he only wanted to smash a windscreen or two and see cars swerve. He drops the slab onto the carriageway as a lorry and several cars approach, the vehicles beneath the bridge travelling at motorway speed. He tells the police that he knew there was a good chance that someone in a vehicle might be seriously hurt, but that he hoped the drivers would avoid the slab and he did not want anyone to die. The slab strikes a windscreen and the driver dies.

Is the man guilty of murder?

Show the answer and explanation
E

Correct answer

No, because he neither intended to kill nor to cause really serious harm; foresight of a risk is not intention.

Murder requires intention to kill or to cause grievous bodily harm; foresight of a serious risk, short of appreciated virtual certainty, is not intention.

He wanted to damage vehicles, not to kill or seriously injure. His admitted foresight of a 'good chance' of serious injury does not amount to appreciating that death or serious harm was virtually certain, so oblique intention is unavailable. Liability would lie in unlawful act manslaughter.

He had no direct intent to kill or cause grievous bodily harm, and foresight of a 'good chance' of serious injury falls well short of appreciating virtual certainty.

  • R v Woollin [1999] 1 AC 82 — Foresight of a risk short of appreciated virtual certainty is not intention.
  • R v Cunningham [1982] AC 566 — Nothing less than intent to kill or cause GBH will satisfy the mens rea of murder.

Rule card

Murder: unlawful killing of a human being with intent to kill or cause GBH. Oblique intent: the jury may find intention where death/serious harm was a virtual certainty and the defendant appreciated that.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Adjacent rule

    Yes, because a reasonable person standing on that footbridge would have realised that death or serious harm was virtually certain to follow from his act.

    Oblique intention requires that the defendant himself appreciated that death or serious harm was a virtual certainty; the reasonable person's view is not the test.

    • R v Woollin [1999] 1 AC 82 — A jury may find intention where death or serious bodily harm was a virtual certainty and the defendant appreciated that it was.
  • B
    Right outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative

    No, because his intention was aimed at the vehicles rather than at any person.

    Right result, wrong reason: the point is not transferred malice but that he lacked any intention to kill or cause really serious harm to anyone.

    Ruled out by: The acquittal of murder does not turn on transferred malice: the slab in fact struck a person, and the true reason is his lack of intention to kill or cause really serious harm.

    • R v Pembliton (1874) LR 2 CCR 119 — Malice directed at property cannot be transferred so as to found liability for an offence against the person.
  • C
    Outdated law

    Yes, because death was a natural and probable consequence of dropping a heavy slab onto vehicles travelling at motorway speed, and he must be taken to have intended that consequence.

    Intention is not to be inferred merely because a result was a natural and probable consequence; the jury must consider all the evidence of what the defendant actually intended.

    • Criminal Justice Act 1967, s.8 — A court is not bound to infer that a defendant intended a result by reason only of its being a natural and probable consequence of his acts.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    Yes, because he was reckless as to causing really serious harm.

    Recklessness is not enough for murder; nothing less than an intention to kill or to cause grievous bodily harm will do.

    • R v Cunningham [1982] AC 566 — The mens rea of murder is an intention to kill or to cause grievous bodily harm.

Read with this question