FLK2, Session 2 · Trial procedure in magistrates’ court and Crown Court

SQE1 Criminal Law and Practice question: Relevance of defendant’s good character

A single best answer question in the SQE1 style. Choose an answer, then open the explanation: the correct option, why each of the others fails, and the authority behind it. No sign-up.

Question 4

Relevance of defendant’s good characterHarder

A man is tried in the Crown Court for theft from his employer. He has no previous convictions, but eighteen months ago he accepted a police caution for shoplifting, and the prosecution has not sought to adduce it. He made no comment in his police interview but gives evidence at trial, denying any dishonesty. His counsel asks the judge for a good character direction.

Which of the following best describes the man's entitlement to a good character direction?

Show the answer and explanation
C

Correct answer

The judge has a discretion to treat him as of effective good character and to give a modified direction.

A caution means he is not of absolute good character, but the judge may treat him as effectively of good character and modify the direction.

Absolute good character requires no convictions and no other reprehensible conduct. A caution accepted eighteen months ago for an offence of dishonesty is such conduct, so the full Vye direction is not his as of right. It does not follow that he gets nothing: the judge retains a discretion to treat him as of effective good character and to give a direction modified to reflect the caution.

With a caution he is not of absolute good character, but the judge may in his discretion treat him as effectively of good character, tailoring the direction to reflect the caution.

  • R v Vye [1993] 1 WLR 471 — The good character direction addresses credibility and propensity.
  • R v Hunter [2015] EWCA Crim 631 — Only absolute good character attracts the direction as of right; otherwise the judge has a discretion to give a modified direction.

Rule card

Absolute good character (no convictions, no other blemish) → Vye direction as of right on credibility and propensity. Blemish → judicial discretion to give a modified 'effective good character' direction.

Why the other options fail

  • A
    Surface reading

    He is entitled to no good character direction, because the caution is an admission of dishonesty.

    A blemish removes the entitlement as of right but does not automatically exclude a modified direction, which remains within the judge's discretion.

  • B
    Adjacent rule

    He is entitled only to the propensity limb, because he made no comment in interview.

    The credibility limb arises because he gives evidence at trial; silence in interview does not remove it.

    • R v Vye [1993] 1 WLR 471 — The credibility limb is given where the defendant testifies or has relied on an exculpatory pre-trial statement.
  • D
    Adjacent rule

    He is entitled to the full direction, because a caution can never be admitted against a defendant as bad character evidence.

    A caution is an admission of reprehensible behaviour and is capable of being deployed as bad character; in any event its existence bears on whether he is of absolute good character.

  • E
    Surface readingClosest alternative

    He is entitled as of right to the full direction on both credibility and propensity, because a caution is not a conviction.

    A caution involves an admission of the offence and is a blemish, so he is not of absolute good character and has no entitlement as of right.

    Ruled out by: He accepted a police caution eighteen months ago, so he is not of absolute good character and the full direction is not available as of right.

    • R v Hunter [2015] EWCA Crim 631 — Only a defendant with no convictions and no other reprehensible conduct is of absolute good character and entitled to the direction as of right.

Read with this question