Question 5
Procedure for appeal against conviction and/or sentenceMediumA man pleaded not guilty to an offence of criminal damage and was tried in the magistrates' court. On 5 March the magistrates convicted him. They adjourned the case for a pre-sentence report and, on 2 April, imposed a community order. The man tells his solicitor that he is content with the community order but wants to challenge his conviction in the Crown Court. He asks whether his notice should be sent to the Crown Court, and says a friend told him he has a month from the day he was found guilty and that a judge must first agree to hear the appeal.
Which of the following correctly states how the man's appeal must be commenced?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer D
Correct answer
Notice of appeal must be filed with the magistrates' court and the CPS within 21 days of sentence.
An appeal from the magistrates' court to the Crown Court is a right, commenced by notice filed with the magistrates' court and served on the CPS within 21 days of sentence.
The man pleaded not guilty, so s 108(1)(b) gives him a right of appeal against conviction. No permission is required. The 21-day period runs from 2 April, the date sentence was passed, even though the appeal is against conviction only.
Having pleaded not guilty he may appeal against conviction as of right, by notice filed with the convicting court and served on the prosecution within 21 days of sentence.
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s.108(1)(b) — A person convicted by a magistrates' court who did not plead guilty may appeal to the Crown Court against the conviction or sentence.
Rule card
MCA 1980 s 108: convicted defendant may appeal to the Crown Court (conviction and/or sentence if not guilty plea; sentence only if guilty plea). Notice within 21 days of sentence, filed with the magistrates' court and served on the CPS; a Crown Court judge may extend time.
Why the other options fail
- AAdjacent rule
He must first obtain the permission of a Crown Court judge to appeal, applying within 28 days of the community order.
Permission and a 28-day notice period belong to appeals from the Crown Court to the Court of Appeal; an appeal under s 108 is a right requiring no permission.
- Criminal Appeal Act 1968, s.9 — An appeal against sentence passed in the Crown Court requires a certificate from the sentencing judge or the leave of the Court of Appeal.
- BSurface reading
The notice of appeal must be filed with the Crown Court alone, within 21 days of the community order being imposed.
The notice is filed with the magistrates' court and served on the CPS; the magistrates' clerk then sends it to the Crown Court.
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s.108(1) — The right of appeal is exercised by giving notice in the magistrates' court that convicted, which transmits the appeal to the Crown Court.
- CAdjacent rule
He may appeal against sentence only, since he was convicted after pleading not guilty, filing notice within 21 days.
It is the defendant who pleaded guilty whose appeal is limited to sentence; a defendant who pleaded not guilty may appeal against conviction.
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s.108(1)(a) — A person who pleaded guilty may appeal only against sentence.
- ESurface readingClosest alternative
He must file notice of appeal with the magistrates' court and the CPS within 21 days of 5 March, the date of conviction.
The 21-day period runs from the date on which sentence was passed, which was 2 April, not from the date of conviction.
Ruled out by: The community order was imposed on 2 April after an adjournment for a pre-sentence report, and time runs from the passing of sentence, not from the conviction on 5 March.
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s.108(1)(b) — A person who did not plead guilty may appeal to the Crown Court against conviction or sentence; the notice period runs from the passing of sentence.