Question 3
Magistrates' court case management directionsMediumAt a preparation for trial hearing the magistrates gave standard directions and fixed a trial date, and the man, aged 19, was warned that if he did not attend the trial would be likely to take place in his absence. He does not attend on the trial date. The prosecutor tells the bench that it has a discretion whether to proceed. The solicitor cannot contact the man and wants an adjournment.
How should the solicitor respond to the prosecutor's statement?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer A
Correct answer
Explain that as the man is 19 the court must proceed unless contrary to the interests of justice, then argue that proceeding in his absence would be contrary to the interests of justice.
The prosecutor misstated the law by claiming the court had a discretion to proceed; because the defendant is 19, section 11(1)(b) of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980 mandates that the court shall proceed unless contrary to the interests of justice, and the solicitor must correct the misstatement before arguing the exception.
Under section 11(1) of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, the court has a discretion whether to proceed only where the accused is under 18 (s 11(1)(a)). Where the defendant has attained the age of 18 (here, the man is 19), section 11(1)(b) provides that the court shall proceed in his absence unless it appears contrary to the interests of justice. Paragraph 2.7 of the SRA Code of Conduct requires the solicitor to draw this provision to the court's attention, after which the solicitor can properly argue that proceeding in the man's absence would be contrary to the interests of justice.
Under section 11(1) of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, the court has a discretion whether to proceed only where the accused is under 18 years of age (section 11(1)(a)); where the accused has attained the age of 18 (here, the man is 19), section 11(1)(b) provides that the court shall proceed in his absence unless it appears contrary to the interests of justice to do so. Paragraph 2.7 of the SRA Code of Conduct requires the solicitor to draw this governing statutory provision to the court's attention, after which the solicitor may properly argue the interests of justice exception.
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s 11(1)(b) — Where an accused who has attained the age of 18 years does not appear at trial, the court shall proceed in his absence unless it appears to the court to be contrary to the interests of justice to do so.
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 2.7 — A solicitor draws the court's attention to relevant statutory provisions of which they are aware and which are likely to have a material effect on the outcome of the proceedings.
Rule card
Trial in absence of defendant (MCA 1980 s 11): under 18, the court may proceed (discretion, s 11(1)(a)); 18 or older, the court shall proceed unless contrary to the interests of justice (duty, s 11(1)(b)). Under SRA Code para 2.7, advocates must draw relevant statutory provisions to the court's attention.
Why the other options fail
- BAdjacent rule
Apply to adjourn under section 11(2A) of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980 on the ground that there is an acceptable reason for the man's failure to appear.
Section 11(2A) of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980 provides that the court shall not proceed if it considers that there is an acceptable reason for the failure to appear. However, because the solicitor has had no contact with the client and knows no reason for his absence, there is no factual basis on which to make such an application.
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s 11(2A) — The court shall not proceed in the absence of the accused if it considers that there is an acceptable reason for his failure to appear.
- CRight outcome, wrong reasonClosest alternative
Tell the bench that section 11 of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980 applies and accept that the trial must proceed today.
While section 11(1)(b) establishes a presumption that the trial shall proceed against an absent defendant who is 18 or older, this duty is subject to the qualification 'unless it appears to the court to be contrary to the interests of justice to do so'. Conceding immediately that the trial must proceed surrenders an argument legitimately available to the defence.
Ruled out by: Section 11(1)(b) of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980 contains an express qualification where proceeding would be contrary to the interests of justice, so immediately conceding that the trial must proceed surrenders an argument open to the defence.
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s 11(1)(b) — The court shall proceed in the absence of an adult defendant unless it appears contrary to the interests of justice to do so.
- DSurface reading
Submit that the trial cannot proceed in the man's absence because he was only warned that trial was 'likely' to proceed rather than that proceeding would be mandatory.
The standard warning that the trial would be likely to take place in the defendant's absence is proper and does not invalidate the operation of section 11(1)(b) of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980. Section 11(1)(b) mandates proceeding unless contrary to the interests of justice, and the solicitor must state the correct statutory test rather than raise an unmerited challenge to the warning.
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s 11(1)(b) — Where an adult defendant does not attend the trial, the court shall proceed in his absence unless it appears contrary to the interests of justice to do so.
- ESurface reading
Say nothing, because the accuracy of submissions about the applicable statutory provision is the prosecutor's responsibility rather than the defence's.
Under paragraph 2.7 of the SRA Code of Conduct, the advocate's duty to draw the court's attention to relevant statutory provisions of which they are aware applies equally to the defence advocate; an advocate must not remain silent when the court is being misdirected on the law.
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 2.7 — A solicitor draws the court's attention to relevant statutory provisions of which they are aware and which are likely to have a material effect on the outcome of the proceedings.