Question 4
Unfair contract termsEasierA man joins an indoor climbing centre, which is run as a business. At reception he signs a notice, printed in large plain type, stating that the centre accepts no liability for injury however caused. He does not read it. During a session an anchor negligently installed by the centre's staff fails and he breaks his wrist. The centre says the term is reasonable, and that climbers voluntarily accept the risks of the sport.
Which of the following best describes the effect of the exclusion term?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer A
Correct answer
The term is not binding on the man.
An exclusion of liability for personal injury caused by negligence is prohibited outright in a consumer contract.
The climbing centre is a trader and the man a consumer. Section 65 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 prevents a trader excluding or restricting liability for personal injury resulting from negligence, so the notice has no effect on his claim for the broken wrist.
In a consumer contract a trader cannot by a term or notice exclude or restrict liability for personal injury resulting from negligence; the term has no effect at all.
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, s 65 — A trader cannot by a term or notice exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence.
Rule card
Consumer contracts: personal injury caused by negligence can never be excluded; other terms are tested for fairness.
Why the other options fail
- BAdjacent rule
The term binds the man because he signed the notice without reading it.
Signature does bind a party to terms at common law, but that rule operates subject to statutory controls, and the statutory ban on excluding personal injury liability applies whatever the consumer signed.
- L'Estrange v F Graucob Ltd [1934] 2 KB 394 — A party who signs a contractual document is bound by its terms whether or not she has read them, subject to statutory control.
- CCivil-law intuition
The term binds the man because he voluntarily accepted the obvious risks of climbing.
A consumer's awareness of a term or notice is not of itself to be taken as voluntary acceptance of the risk, and the exclusion remains ineffective.
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, s 65 — A person is not to be taken to have voluntarily accepted a risk merely because he agreed to or knew about a term or notice excluding liability for negligence.
- DAdjacent ruleClosest alternative
The term binds the man if the centre shows it is fair and transparent.
The fairness assessment governs most consumer terms, but an exclusion of liability for negligently caused personal injury is prohibited outright and never binds, however fairly expressed.
Ruled out by: The injury is personal injury caused by the staff's negligent installation, which falls under the outright ban rather than the fairness assessment; the term's plain type and apparent reasonableness are irrelevant.
- Consumer Rights Act 2015, s 62 — An unfair term in a consumer contract is not binding on the consumer; fairness turns on significant imbalance contrary to good faith.
- EOutdated law
The term binds the man to the extent that it satisfies the reasonableness test in UCTA 1977.
UCTA's reasonableness control now governs non-consumer contracts; consumer contracts are governed by the 2015 Act, under which this exclusion is simply of no effect.
- Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, s 2 — Business liability for negligence cannot be excluded for death or personal injury, and other loss only so far as the term is reasonable.