Question 5
Liquidated sums and penaltiesMediumA farmer engaged a contractor to build a grain store on land the farmer holds as tenant of an agricultural holding. The contract provided that the contractor would pay the farmer £2,000 for each day of delay in completion. When the contract was made, £2,000 a day was a reasonable forecast of the farmer's likely loss. Completion was 10 days late. The farmer's actual loss from the delay was about £6,000, and he made no attempt to hire temporary storage.
What is the farmer entitled to recover from the contractor for the delay?
Show the answer and explanationAnswer C
Correct answer
The farmer may recover £20,000 under the clause, because a valid liquidated damages clause fixes the sum recoverable irrespective of the loss actually suffered.
A valid liquidated damages clause is enforced as agreed: the farmer recovers £2,000 for each of the 10 days, not the smaller loss he actually suffered.
£2,000 a day was a reasonable forecast of loss when the contract was made, so the clause is not penal. The agreed sum is then recoverable without proof of loss and without regard to mitigation, giving £20,000.
£2,000 a day was a reasonable forecast when the contract was made, so the clause is a valid liquidated damages provision and the agreed sum is payable for the 10 days' delay.
- Cellulose Acetate Silk Co Ltd v Widnes Foundry (1925) Ltd [1933] AC 20 — The agreed sum under a valid clause is recoverable, neither more nor less.
Rule card
Valid liquidated damages clause: the stipulated sum is payable, neither more nor less, without proof of actual loss. Penalty is judged at formation by proportionality to the legitimate interest, not by hindsight comparison with the loss suffered.
Why the other options fail
- AAdjacent rule
The farmer's recovery is limited to the loss actually suffered, because the grain store is on an agricultural holding he holds as tenant.
That restriction applies to a landlord recovering liquidated damages from his tenant under a contract of tenancy of an agricultural holding. Here the claimant is the tenant and the contract is a building contract.
- Agricultural Holdings Act 1986, s.24 — A landlord may not recover, in consequence of a breach of a term of a contract of tenancy of an agricultural holding, any sum in excess of the damage actually suffered.
- BSurface readingClosest alternative
The farmer may recover nothing under the clause, because £20,000 is more than three times his actual loss.
The clause is tested as at the date of contracting against the legitimate interest protected; a reasonable forecast at that date is not made penal by a smaller loss in the event.
Ruled out by: When the contract was made £2,000 a day was a reasonable forecast of the farmer's likely loss, so the clause was not out of all proportion at formation.
- Cavendish Square Holding BV v Talal El Makdessi [2015] UKSC 67 — Whether a clause is penal is judged at the time of contracting by reference to proportionality to the legitimate interest in performance.
- DAdjacent rule
The farmer may recover £20,000 only if he shows he tried to reduce his loss by hiring temporary storage.
A claim for an agreed sum is a liquidated claim in which the claimant need prove no loss; mitigation is irrelevant to it.
- British Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Co Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Co of London Ltd [1912] AC 673 — A claimant seeking damages must take reasonable steps to mitigate its loss.
- ERight outcome, wrong reason
The farmer may recover only £6,000, because damages for breach of contract are compensatory.
The compensatory principle governs unliquidated damages. Where the parties have validly agreed the sum payable on breach, that sum is recoverable without proof of loss.
- Robinson v Harman (1848) 1 Exch 850 — Damages place the claimant in the position performance would have produced.